To Mayor Bill Peduto, it is the “next big step” in the redevelopment of the former Civic Arena site. But to one Hill District leader, it represents a “misstep.”

Both were reacting Thursday to the hiring of the world-renowned Danish architectural firm Bjarke Ingels Group by the Pittsburgh Penguins and housing developer McCormack Baron Salazar to design the residences and public spaces that will be part of the 28-acre redevelopment.

Mr. Peduto, who saw some of BIG’s work during a visit to Denmark last year and participated with one of its partners in the P4 conference in Pittsburgh in April, saw the firm’s involvement in the former arena site as building on the city’s architectural legacy.

“We’re looking at a way of not just building buildings there but building buildings that will connect people with place and creating special uniqueness within that place that will become 50 years from now what people identify as the special part of Pittsburgh,” he said.

Advertise with us

BIG, which is known for cutting-edge architecture that includes a ski slope on the top of waste treatment plant and a Manhattan flood control project that’s barriers double as public parks, will take the lead in designing the site’s 1,100 residences.

A secondary charge will be to help find ways to reconnect the lower Hill District property with Downtown and other parts of the Hill. That is one of the primary goals of the city, Allegheny County, and the Penguins in completing the redevelopment, expected to top $500 million.

BIG, Mr. Peduto said, is probably the top-ranked firm worldwide in “placemaking — using public space in order to create an identity and also on a scale for people.”

But not everybody was pleased with the hiring.

Marimba Milliones, CEO and president of the Hill Community Development Corp., said the Penguins and McCormack Baron should have done a request for proposals and reached out to local and minority firms before selecting an architect.

Advertise with us

To not do so was a “misstep,” she argued, adding that the hiring was not in keeping with the stated goals of the arena project in maximizing opportunities for minorities and others.

“I think it rings tone deaf,” she said.

A key part of the redevelopment is a community collaboration and implementation plan signed by Hill leaders, local politicians and the Penguins that addresses issues such as minority hiring and affordable housing.

“This is not about BIG. I’m sure BIG is more than capable of doing the work. This is about access to opportunity and fair competition,” Ms. Milliones said.

But Mr. Peduto took exception to such comments. He said private developers have the right to hire whomever they want to do such work.

Advertise with us

“I think Shadyside would be honored to have an internationally-recognized architect coming in to help design their plans. I think that Lawrenceville would be honored,” he said.

“We are providing the Hill District with a world-recognized architectural firm. It’s not about the contract or the money. It’s about what the legacy will be for the Hill District. I would be shocked to find out that the residents of the Hill would be upset that they’re getting one of the best architects in the world to help to design their public space and the design of the buildings.”

Travis Williams, the Penguins’ chief operating officer, said the team is committed to reaching the goals set in the community agreement as part of the overall redevelopment. It is not meant to apply to every element or every contract, he said.

Mr. Williams added that BIG will be hiring other architects as part of its work and that there will be opportunities for local and minority firms.

BIG, with offices in Copenhagen and New York, is well known for the level of community participation it brings to its design work and is expected to do extensive community outreach, including charettes, as part of the arena planning.

Advertise with us

Residential construction is expected to start in late 2016.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.