It’s back to the drawing boards in the city’s bid to redevelop the Strip District produce terminal, with one developer out and another in.

The city Urban Redevelopment Authority board turned to Pittsburgh Gateways Corp. and Chicago-based McCaffery Interests Thursday to come up with another proposal to remake the 1,533-foot-long warehouse that for decades was a wholesale produce hub.

In awarding the 120 days of exclusive negotiations to the pair, the URA cut ties with Pittsburgh-based developer Rubino Partners, which it had selected along with McCaffery last September to fashion a plan for the terminal, one built around residences and a marketplace.

But McCaffery never met with Rubino, and no partnership ever emerged, prompting the URA to turn to Pittsburgh Gateways, the nonprofit economic development group behind the redevelopment of the former Connelley Trade School in the Hill District, for help.

Advertise with us

“This has been a marathon of a project. But I’m confident that we have the right people at the table to come back to us at some point in the future to develop something that could be great for the city,” said Kevin Acklin, URA board chairman and chief of staff to Mayor Bill Peduto.

Mr. Acklin said Rubino’s plan to convert the terminal into a giant marketplace anchored by vendors selling closeout merchandise “didn’t fit” with McCaffery’s plan, one that was largely residential in nature.

Mike Rubino, head of Rubino Partners, “does not intend to comment,” a spokesperson said.

McCaffery and Pittsburgh Gateways will work over the next four months to come up with a plan and financing for the URA-owned building, a landmark that is now largely vacant.

Just what the plan will be has yet to be determined, though representatives for both developers said they will be looking at possible “civic options” and “public uses.”

Advertise with us

While housing was the cornerstone of McCaffery’s original plan for the building, president Ed Woodbury said he didn’t know how much would be included in the new proposal.

Asked whether a public market would be part of the plan, Robert Meeder, Pittsburgh Gateways CEO and president, said, “We’ll see. We definitely hear the voices and we want to continue those conversations to see what evolves from that.”

Mr. Acklin said possible retail, residential, farm-to-table and restaurant uses are “still on the table” as part of a proposed redevelopment but stressed that the final plan ultimately would be left to McCaffery and Pittsburgh Gateways.

“We feel like we have the right people at the table with the right experience,” he said.

He added that Mr. Peduto is looking for a “transformational development that is economically viable yet provides for a public use that benefits the public at large.”

Advertise with us

The goal, Mr. Woodbury said, is to redevelop the terminal in a way that would complement the Strip’s popular Penn Avenue retail corridor and the Buncher Co. development on the riverfront behind it.

Buncher plans to go before the city planning commission next week with a proposal to build a five-story, 365-unit luxury apartment building near the terminal as part of its $450 million Riverfront Landing residential and office development. Construction is expected to start early next year.

Mr. Acklin said the latest plan for the terminal “does call for some access,” such as pass-throughs, but wasn’t sure whether that would be for vehicles or pedestrians.

URA board member Jim Ferlo said he was concerned that the new development could negatively impact Strip merchants and the “successful retail anarchy” that Penn Avenue has become.

Mr. Ferlo also said he wants to see the property returned to the tax rolls as part of any redevelopment. Mr. Acklin agreed, adding that the city is looking at using part of the tax revenue generated from the development to fund improvements on other parts of Smallman Street.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh Gateways was encouraged to become involved in the terminal discussions by the Heinz Endowments, which has an interest in the redevelopment and potentially could help to fund it. Pittsburgh Gateways has met with McCaffery seven or eight times in recent months.

The economic development nonprofit is best known for its work at the former Connelley school. It bought the 233,822-square-foot building in 2011 from the Pittsburgh Public Schools and spearheaded its conversion into the Energy Innovation Center.

As part of that $37 million project, it pulled together more than two dozen different investors and partners. The city hopes to rely on that expertise to craft a funding plan for the terminal, particularly since the public aspects probably won’t generate lots of revenue.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.