The second tightest Class A office market in the country could be loosening considerably over the next three years, according to one local real estate firm.

In its latest Skyline report, Jones Lang LaSalle predicted that the vacancy rate for Class A space Downtown could double from 5 percent to 10 percent by mid 2018 because of new construction and consolidations.

“There are a couple of very large blocks of space coming on the market,” said Dan Adamski, JLL managing director.

Higher vacancy rates could put pressure on landlords who have been charging top dollar for Class A space to lower their rents and offer more concessions.

Advertise with us

JLL expects the vacancy rate to increase when U.S. Steel moves out of U.S. Steel Tower Downtown to its new headquarters at the former Civic Arena site in 2017, potentially leaving 470,000 square feet of space vacant in the city’s tallest building.

Also factored in is BNY Mellon’s decision to vacate more than 600,000 square feet in 525 William Penn Place by early 2018 with plans to move about 1,500 employees to BNY Mellon Center on Grant Street or its client service center on Ross Street.

Likewise, the new Tower Two-Sixty, formerly known as the Gardens at Market Square, will be ready early next year, adding another 128,000 square feet of office space to the market. JLL will vacate its offices at 525 William Penn Place to move into the new building as its anchor tenant.

In predicting that the vacancy rate will rise to 10 percent, JLL, in essence, doesn’t think the space will be filled by new tenants coming into Downtown or current ones expanding.

Mr. Adamski said it will be an “interesting test of the market” to see if all the empty space can be leased before it officially becomes available in two to three years. He’s not banking on it.

Advertise with us

“My sense is that it is a large volume of space for a market of this size to absorb,” he said. “My prediction is that it won’t all be filled.”

While U.S. Steel Tower and 525 William Penn Place may attract new tenants, Mr. Adamski suspects they “will be cannibalizing” them from other buildings, causing vacancies elsewhere in the Golden Triangle.

The jump in the vacancy rate could be quite a shock for the Downtown market, which JLL now ranks as the second tightest in the United States behind Bellevue, Wash.

Nonetheless, Mr. Adamski believes “trophy buildings” like PPG Place, BNY Mellon Center, One Oxford Centre and Fifth Avenue Place would be largely unaffected by the potential rise in the vacancy rate.

Those buildings, he said, offer the highest quality space, are nearly full, and are coveted. He doesn’t expect that to change, enabling landlords to maintain high rents.

Advertise with us

Older buildings like U.S. Steel Tower and 525 William Penn Place, on the other hand, are “going to have to be aggressive to fill the space,” he said.

He said he also has heard that at least part of William Penn Place could be converted into residences or a hotel. “If it doesn’t stay office, that definitely changes the dynamics,” he noted.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.