Point Park University has pledged to Mayor Bill Peduto that it will “incorporate” three turn-of-the-century Forbes Avenue facades into the design of the new Pittsburgh Playhouse in Downtown.

But the commitment has done little to appease local preservation groups, one of which is thinking about nominating the buildings at 320, 322 and 330 Forbes for a city historic designation.

Point Park has been meeting with Mr. Peduto and preservationists for months in an effort to find a way to salvage the Beaux Arts facade of the former Honus Wagner sporting goods store at 320 Forbes and those on two adjacent buildings at 322 and 330 Forbes.

As a result of the concerns, the university “has agreed to carefully deconstruct all three historical facades on Forbes Avenue and incorporate them seamlessly into the design of the new playhouse,” said Kevin Acklin, Mr. Peduto’s chief of staff.

Advertise with us

Point Park won’t reveal its formal plans until Dec. 4, but it doesn’t appear as if it will build the $75 million playhouse complex around the facades themselves.

Rather, the facades “will be preserved and tactfully integrated into the overall design of the building itself, perhaps as framing for windows or other elements,” Mr. Acklin said.

Rob Pfaffmann, a Downtown architect who has been involved in the discussions with the mayor’s office and the university, said his understanding is that all three facades will be dismantled and moved to a playhouse courtyard off Forbes, where they will be placed on walls.

“The relocation of an architectural facade like this is problematic, because it turns the architecture into a wall hanging, an artifact of the past rather than a living building,” he said.

Ellen Kitzerow, the chairwoman of the Young Preservationists Association of Pittsburgh who also has been at some of the meetings about the playhouse, said she believes at least two of the facades will be moved to the courtyard.

Advertise with us

While that’s “certainly better than them being demolished,” Ms. Kitzerow said, she would be disappointed if that turns out to be the case. The Young Preservationists recently included the buildings on its list of best preservation opportunities.

“We feel that moving them from the street would be just a real loss for the aesthetics and keeping the architectural heritage of that street intact. These are important buildings to the business district,” she said.

But Mr. Acklin disputed claims that the facades would become little more than wall hangings.

To say all three “will be on a brick wall in the park, I don’t think that is something that’s being proposed,” he said. “They’re just not going to be pinned upon a wall. They will be part of the actual building itself.”

Mariann Geyer, Point Park’s vice president of external affairs, declined to discuss specifics regarding the reuse of the facades, saying all of that will be revealed Dec. 4.

Advertise with us

“We are very happy that we had the opportunity to work with a variety of groups and the mayor to come to what we hope will be something that represents and honors the history of the Forbes Avenue corridor,” she said.

Point Park has been tussling with preservationists over the three buildings for more than a year. It began meeting with Preservation Pittsburgh last year after the group threatened to nominate the properties as city historic structures. Mr. Peduto became involved after he became mayor in January.

In July 2013, the city planning commission approved the demolition of the buildings after receiving assurances from the college that it would do everything possible to preserve the facades.

At the time, Point Park said it would deconstruct the Honus Wagner facade, with its scrolled brackets, swags and wreaths, and reassemble it in the proposed courtyard.

It also vowed to preserve as much as possible the fronts of the other two structures, a two-story classical revival building and a three-story Beaux Arts building. Both were to be incorporated into parts of the playhouse design.

Advertise with us

Ms. Kitzerow said her group is considering nominating the buildings as city historic structures. While that doesn’t guarantee that the facades would be saved, it could tie up the playhouse project for months as the nomination moved through the city bureaucracy.

“It would be much better to keep the facades where they are and have the rest of the buildings take the facades into account rather than move the facades around,” she said.

Point Park has made relocating the playhouse from Oakland a priority. The complex will feature a new five-story building and incorporate the existing University Center and Stock Exchange Building on Fourth Avenue. Among the amenities will be two black box theaters with flexible seating; a 560-seat proscenium/​thrust theater; rehearsal studios; a sound stage; and scene, paint and prop shops.