Even though the iPhone and various Google Android phones have been on the market for a while, I still get lots of questions related to which one to choose. So here is my guide to choosing between iPhone and Android. Determine which of these criteria are most important to you when making your own buying decision.

Let's start with ease of use -- an Apple trademark. Here, the iPhone, as expected, wins hands down. Turn on the power, slide to unlock and touch one of the icons to get your app. The icons are large, well labeled and consistent; and there is only one hardware button on the face of the phone. Not much thinking involved.

But ease of use usually means less flexibility, which is why Android phones win handily on the flexibility front. Not only can you buy lots of different Android models from various manufacturers, but they are also more flexible in the way that you can set them up and configure them to your individual preferences.

Battery life is not bad on the iPhone 4. I find it needs to be charged daily, but I usually don't have a low battery problem during the course of the day. Most Androids are similar, although some of the 4G Android models are horrid on battery life. Your usage patterns and how far you are from the cell tower have a huge impact on how long your battery lasts.

Advertise with us

The iPhone's battery is sealed and not replaceable, which means it will never win this battle in my mind. But it won't always lose, either -- because some Android models don't let you replace the battery, either. Most Androids I've reviewed do allow the user to replace the battery; so give a slight edge to Android here. (Choose your Android model carefully if you want a removable battery.)

How well does the phone react to touch? This is a combination of whether it recognizes your touch in the right place on the screen and whether it has the performance to act promptly after you touch the screen or hardware key.

This is the toughest to judge, because it depends on what you're doing with the phone -- playing a game, watching a video, surfing the Web, texting or phone calling for instance. While I have found results vary significantly, I'd have to give the edge to Android here -- because the iPhone 4 often takes a long time to respond to my touch.

This morning, it waited three seconds per touch to enter my letters while texting -- then didn't seem to send. Two minutes later, I noticed the phone sending my text message. Most of the time it responds immediately; but that delayed performance has occurred frequently enough to know it's an issue.

A lot has been made about the larger app store for the iPhone. But let's face it, it matters only if the app you want is not available on the phone you have. I haven't yet found myself without being able to do something because I could find the app for only the phone not in my hand. So with thousands of apps available for both phones, this is a clear tie.

Advertise with us

I'm still not a fan of having a proprietary connector on the cord that connects to your PC. Apple uses its own connector; most Androids use a standard microUSB. But it's less of a concern these days because Apple has been consistent over the past few years.

The final consideration is whether you want the ultimate cool factor. If that's your most important decision point, there's still no choice other than iPhone.