The banking world has changed -- not just the home mortgage approval processes and change in interest rates on savings accounts. I'm talking about the simple day-to-day banking changes that make it challenging to do business. Some of it is technology driven, but it's mostly policy driven, spurred to unusual levels by uncontrolled use of technology. I work with a number of banks as a representative of several companies, and find many of the policies strange; others laughable.
Wells Fargo of California bought North Carolina-based Wachovia and took several years to digest the acquired company. I am in charge of checking and credit accounts that were to be moved to Wells Fargo from Wachovia with the merger -- certainly a difficult task for the merging banks.
The checking account was transferred before the credit account by a full year, giving me initial concern that there would be problems during the period that the accounts would at separate banks. But the combined company handled that flawlessly. All the transfers went well; and the support organization was well trained to handle potential issues for businesses that end up with accounts opened in a single bank, now separated. So I breathed a sigh of relief, thinking Wells Fargo would be terrific.
But I guess I let my guard down too soon. The problems didn't happen until after both accounts were together again -- this time at Wells Fargo instead of Wachovia. Wells Fargo simply couldn't deal with overpayments on the credit account the way Wachovia had done. So whenever I paid more than we owed -- something I did routinely at Wachovia -- my overpayments threw their systems for a loop. Instead of simply showing that the bank owed me money (a negative balance), the overpayment locked the account.
Not only did I not have access to my credit for close to a month, the bank held the excess money that I paid over the balance as well. I had to speak to telephone representatives six times, and get a lecture from support never to overpay the account again. It finally worked out; but not without a lot of heartache -- because the bank middle managers let the technology lead them instead of letting the technology help them. Their client lost -- so the bank lost lots of credibility.
Similarly, I was very impressed when Citizens Bank started offering to transfer money between your Citizens account and your accounts at other banks via your online account. Big win ... until I tried it. If you transfer money from the other bank into Citizens, the other bank releases the money the next day; but Citizens doesn't show that it is in your Citizens account for another week -- as if you ordered the transaction from the other bank's website and Citizens didn't know the transaction was happening.
It's almost impossible to have a full banking relationship with any bank like we had 20 years ago -- because what you think is a bank is actually a collection of companies that have the same name, but are almost unrelated. You might have a relationship with the branch manager down the street with you but the decision to give you that credit card is being made by somebody in the credit card company; and he doesn't care whether you have a business relationship with the local branch. You might see your PNC Payroll online account in the same interface as your checking account; but it's a separate company that services many banks.
I hope that bank leaders see that over time this leads to decay of their brands and their customer relationships.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.