Since the first commercial transaction took place on the Internet, a war has been brewing -- a war over taxation not unlike the one that caused our forefathers to participate in the Boston Tea Party in 1773.

On one side are traditional retailers and state taxing authorities. They want to tax sales made over the Internet. The retailers claim Internet-only firms that don't have to collect sales tax have an unfair advantage. The states see it as another form of revenue in a difficult economy.

On the other side are the big Internet retailers, such as Amazon and Overstock, which want to maintain their sales tax-free status. They have been protected in the past by federal laws that prohibit taxes across state lines, and want to keep that protection.

But it's the middle man that is being used as pawns in this high-stakes battle.

Advertise with us

Over the past decade, Amazon and other online retailers have offered independent website operators (affiliates) a percentage of any sale that is directly associated with a link from that website, if that site is an official affiliate and uses special links to promote Amazon.

Traditionally, states have not collected sales tax from the Internet retailer nor from its affiliates.

Now a handful of states realized that they can pass laws (so-called "Amazon Tax laws") that tax the sales of these big online-only retailers by claiming the online retailers have local business operations through the affiliates that are in their respective states.

Amazon and Overstock have reacted by cutting ties with their affiliates in the states that pass these laws. If you follow the real activity, though, these moves are sleight-of-hand magic.

Let's say the affiliates are in California, whose Amazon Tax law was recently passed. (Pennsylvania, Florida, New York and a handful of other states either have or are likely to pass similar bills).

Advertise with us

California requires online retailers to pay sales tax because the sale started at the affiliate website which has an operation in California. Amazon and Overstock cut ties with their affiliates in California and publicized it voraciously. Now, they say, they are no longer subject to sales tax in that state.

It would seem that this part of the story is over; but that's where the slight-of-hand magic comes in. Amazon's 10,000 affiliates in California are not likely to remove their affiliate links overnight -- and I suspect most will never remove them. So Amazon will get the benefit of affiliate referrals without the cost.

Overstock took the PR aspect a step further by saying it would move the money it was spending on California affiliates to a program for its big California spenders that is meant to help them purchase more. (Those are my words based on what the program does -- not Overstock's words.) Neither Amazon nor Overstock's news release tells affiliates how to remove their links; and I could find nothing on their websites that describes how.

I have posted on megabyteminute.com links to both news releases and to a website for an organization that purports to represent local retailers in this battle.