Remember when the iPhone first hit AT&T -- and the public flocked to the device and clogged up the AT&T Network? When the rumors started that Verizon Wireless would have the iPhone, the immediate reaction from many was that Verizon Wireless' network wouldn't fare much better. Others said Verizon Wireless, with two additional years to build out its network, would do fine, learning from AT&T's mistakes.

So when Verizon Wireless finally released the iPhone 4, bloggers and tech journalist ran out to get the device so they could see whether the Verizon Wireless network would stand up to the iPhone's popularity. They rushed their reviews to market -- claiming the network withstood the test -- likely accurate at a time when few VZW iPhones were around.

Unfortunately, those test results were seriously flawed, because they were not testing with a full load. But now, we're months down the road, and Verizon, having sold 2.2 million iPhones in the first quarter alone, has a much more heavily utilized network than it did when those reviewers rushed out to get their iPhone 4s on Verizon. So it's finally time to do a more accurate review.

I live in Pittsburgh, a high-tech mecca, but one that wasn't subjected to the AT&T congestion problems caused by iPhones at the same level as the problems in California and New York. So to do the test right, I needed a road trip.

Advertise with us

After using the iPhone in Pittsburgh for several days with no problems getting signal, I took a trip to Connecticut and New York, expecting to encounter congestion problems. But riding in the car and talking on the phone was no problem -- clear signal from Hartford to New York with no disconnects, and I even got a signal in basements of homes while there. The big challenge was to make sure I was in the right seat of the car while testing -- because those states have laws prohibiting use of cell phones while driving.

My California test was not quite as successful; but I wouldn't say that I encountered consistent congestion accessing the VZW network. With the iPhone in use most of the way from San Fernando Valley (north of Los Angeles) to Long Beach (south of LA), I was able to ride comfortably while talking on the phone. (Again, my associate did the driving.) But I had consistent problems getting good service near LAX, Los Angeles' International Airport. Several calls disconnected; and I couldn't get a connection for up to 15 minutes.

Back in Pittsburgh for several weeks, the iPhone works generally well for phone calls. Surprisingly, I have found more problems getting 3G data connections to download data, using the Web browser and connecting via the GoogleVoice Internet telephone service. I believe that the problem is more due to the local performance of the iPhone, though, because other apps also work slowly -- and often the touch screen doesn't react to my touch for several seconds as if the phone has locked up.

In my part of town, Verizon service has always been spotty, because it uses only three cell phone sites to service a large area. So I doubt the lack of 3G availability is due to too many iPhones being used for data. Since Verizon uses CDMA, which separates voice and data, that would be a logical conclusion. I have found little difference in signal quality by holding the phone differently.