Justin Johnson stood in the deli line at a North Side Giant Eagle, wireless earbuds inserted but still able to overhear chatter about Wednesday morning’s big news: Grocery giant Kroger plans to acquire Giant Eagle for $1.65 billion.

He shook his head.

“Giant Eagle had its flaws,” he said. “But it was ours.”

Johnson, 46 of Manchester, said “the emotional impact sucks.” He said the news reminds him of when Macy’s acquired and rebranded the iconic Pittsburgh Kaufmann’s department store in 2005.

Advertise with us

“Nothing we can do,” he said. “We just got to roll with the new. We’ll see what their standard is.”

For people shopping at Giant Eagle and Market District in the city Wednesday morning, reactions to the news ranged from “what will happen to the employees?” to “I don’t care unless the prices go down.”

Burt Flickinger thinks they will.

Flickinger, managing director of Strategic Resource Group, an international consumer industry consulting firm with a focus on retail, said the Kroger-Giant Eagle duo should be a win for everybody. Flickinger said he has worked with six consecutive Kroger CEOs, and with Giant Eagle’s leaders for decades.

“You can expect Kroger to lower prices at Giant Eagle 2.5% to 3.5% the first year, and over the next three to four years, lower prices 6% to 8%,” Flickinger said. “You’ll also see more competitive prices on milk because Kroger has more manufacturing plants than anybody in America, including Costco and Walmart.”

Advertise with us

Flickinger said the acquisition could create jobs in manufacturing, service and retail, support local farmers and create a “whole vendor community,” because Kroger is known for platforming local products. He said to expect an expansion of Kroger-Giant Eagle stores “to create a national supermarket chain,” which opens up the eastern Great Lakes region, Middle Atlantic states, and all of New England for business.

‘Nobody would even know’

Shoppers Wednesday morning said they’ll believe the lower prices when they see them.

“What difference does it make?” Darlene Wade, 45, of the North Side said. “I don't think it’s going to make any difference in the prices.”

Wade prefers Walmart over Giant Eagle and commented on ever-rising grocery prices in the Pittsburgh chain.

When Gerald Clark was a kid in the 1950s, he said, Krogers were everywhere in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

On Wednesday, he stood in the Waterworks Plaza Market District with his wife, Deborah, wondering why everything keeps changing. The couple said they like Giant Eagle’s meat selection and fresh produce. Their favorite brands are always a shelf away. They worry that the acquisition could lead to store closures.

“We’re in our 70s and everything is moving further away from where we live [in Harmar],” Clark said.

But a lot of things might stay the same.

A Giant Eagle associate, who preferred to be unnamed because they were not authorized to speak on behalf of the company, said employees got an email with the news just after 7 a.m. Wednesday.

“I was slightly shocked about it, but they’re not changing the brand,” the associate said. “Quite frankly, if this was never reported, nobody would even know.

Advertise with us

“Nothing really is going to change here. They say that they’re not doing anything with corporate, so we’re all good.”

‘Like a Walmart on steroids’

Dillan Milligan stood in Giant Eagle for the first time ever on Wednesday morning, gathering groceries for the Airbnb he and his friends were staying in.

Milligan, 32, from Austin, Texas, was visiting Pittsburgh for Anthrocon, one of the world’s biggest anthropomorphic conventions, hosted annually in Pittsburgh. He’s used to shopping at Kroger and Albertsons in the South. To him, there’s little difference between national grocers.

“Kroger is basically like this, except it’s a different label,” Milligan said, looking around. “Every grocery store is the same.”

Others said they didn’t care, as long as they can keep their grocery trips the way they like them.

Advertise with us

“As long as people have their jobs, they have the products that I want, the same service and acknowledgement that I usually have when I come to the store — I’m fine,” said Lessie Blake, 79, of Homewood.

Others questioned why the Ohio-based grocer wanted anything to do with Pittsburgh after pulling out of the market entirely in the 1980s.

“I think it’s weird,” said Julie Sargeant, of Oakmont, as she shopped in the Waterworks Plaza Market District. “I used to work in West Virginia, and Kroger was there, it was just ginormous. It was like a Walmart on steroids.”

Ed Boutros, 57 of Aspinwall, said he’s wary of “everything” consolidating, and reducing competition.

“That’s the whole problem. I mean, everything consolidates from internet services to hospitals,” Boutros said. “There is an illusion of choice.”