Customers’ first impression of Oakmont Candle Works is the distinct aroma — a mixture of dozens of candle varieties that tends to drift out from behind the front door and spread along Allegheny Avenue, the town’s main drag.

But that soothing introduction belies the store’s tumultuous start.

It was a childhood dream realized when Tabatha Flanick launched the small business in 2019. And it was nearly derailed soon after by the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, followed by a middle-of-the-night break-in that left her startled and shaken.

“It’s just stuff that can’t be replaced,” she said, recalling the 2020 event when an intruder smashed through Oakmont Candle Works’ front window and began rifling through her personal belongings, ultimately making off with hundreds of dollars in cash and priceless personal belongings.

Advertise with us

But Ms. Flanick’s story is one of resilience.

And Oakmont Candle Works bounced back quickly, even through times of great adversity.

Ms. Flanick, 50, is originally from Fawn Township, but she likes to say that she grew up in her family’s small gift shop in Butler. Everyone pitched in to keep the store going, she recalled. Her father and uncle built furniture, her aunt made crafts, her grandmother sewed.

Growing up in that entrepreneurial environment, Ms. Flanick knew early on that she wanted to run her own gift store or coffee shop some day. And she found that the gift shop idea “kept tugging at the (heart) strings.”

She moved to Oakmont 22 years ago, shortly after she got married to her husband, Joe, who works as an electrician. For years, Ms. Flanick focused on raising her four children, Joey, Gracie, Jack, and Lyla. Once her youngest children were able to “fend for themselves,” she said, she decided it was time to make her mark and start her business.

Advertise with us
Gardenia-scented candles are displayed on shelves at Oakmont Candle Works, on Wednesday, March 19, 2025. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

She learned that the town’s candle shop, Oakmont Candle Company, was closing. She didn’t want to buy the store outright, but she negotiated a deal to buy its burners and melters to get her operation up and running.

And Oakmont Candle Works was born.

Pandemic shutdowns bring unique opportunity

Shortly after opening, Ms. Flanick was forced to close.

It was March, 2020, and the COVID-19 shutdowns had begun.

Then came the break in.

Advertise with us

Ms. Flanick recalled receiving word that police were at her shop. When she arrived on scene, she stepped past the broken glass and took stock of the losses. The burglar had rifled through Ms. Flanick’s belongings and, stumbling through the store’s darkened interior, shattered a prized antique, a wrought iron stand that held a ceramic flowerpot. He stole hundreds of dollars from a drawer near the cash register, stuffing the money into another cherished antique, an ornate wastebasket with illustrations of castles on the exterior.

The items were never recovered.

While she was disheartened by the break-in, Ms. Flanick focused on the positive: None of her merchandise had been carried away.

So she got back to work.

Weeks later, with plans to restart production, Ms. Flanick and her family restocked. With the pandemic ongoing, she managed to attract a unique clientele — people who at that time were spending their waking hours rescuing others: frontline hospital workers.

Advertise with us

She recalled receiving a massive order from a major hospital system for candles to be sent to staff all over the country. She designed the candles with reassuring messages for the workers. She chose relaxing scents, such as lavender.

The Oakmont Candle Works opened in 2019, right before the COVID-19 pandemic shutdowns. The store was also broken into, with the burglar making off with cash and antiques. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Overnight, Oakmont Candle Works turned from a serene storefront to a bustling shipping department.

“It was me, my mom, and my husband down here, and we just had a production line,” Ms. Flanick recalled. “I’m not kidding, there (were) 1,500 candles that went out for all the people that had worked in the health field.”

Ms. Flanick’s customers generally pay for shipping, but when local healthcare workers started ordering from her store, she made a special exception.

Every Tuesday and Thursday, she would load her car with candles and go porch-to-porch throughout the region to hand-deliver her candles — trying, she explained, to bring “a little bit of joy” to customers enduring a dark time.

Advertise with us

“I got notes and gift cards and big banners when I would come up that would thank me for doing that,” she recalled. “It’s something that I’ll never forget.”

Where customers can make their own candles

Ms. Flanick’s candles are all made in a warehouse behind her storefront. They are designed to be environmentally friendly, made from soy wax without phosphates or phthalates that can be common in commercially produced candles, and they come in reusable, recyclable glass containers.

The candle-making process is “very tedious” and depends on the kind of wax being used, Ms. Flanick said. The wax is placed in a jacket and heated in water at temperatures of 150 to 170 degrees. From there, the wax is “fractionalized” as Ms. Flanick mixes in precise measurements of other elements, including fragrances.

“There’s a lot of math, which — I’m not a math person, so I had to retrain myself,” Ms. Flanick said.

She works with two chemists who supply her with fragrances. She names the scents herself, based on the imagery they bring to mind, including “The Pope” — a candle that combines the smell of incense and myrrh akin to a Sunday church service — and “Cozy Flannel” — which harkens a “manly cologne smell.” There’s also the self-explanatory “Mall Pretzel,” she added.

Advertise with us

The back of the store features the “Pour Bar,” a setting where customers make their own candles, pulling various combinations from 68 fragrances stacked on a nearby shelf. The earnest would-be candle makers wick their own jars, blend the fragrances, stir in the wax and finish it off with a custom label.

Tabitha Flanick, owner of Oakmont Candle Works, pours melted wax into glass jars to make candles on Wednesday, March 19, 2025. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Next to the Pour Bar is the Maker’s Room, a dimly-lit space where other local artisans host pop-up events and classes.

“We have a cookie lady that will come in and teach people how to ice fancy cookies, we have a crocheter… I just met them being a creator myself,” Ms. Flanick said.

Ms. Flanick’s peak sales months are from August through December.

“Right after the fourth of July, you have people in here… They're ready for the pumpkin and the warm, cozy scents,” she said. “And then as soon as Halloween is over, they're ready for those holiday scents.”

Advertise with us

This year’s busy season could be a bit different for Ms. Flanick with the U.S. Open headed to the famous Oakmont Country Club just down the street in June.

‘This is my shop and I built this’

To prepare, she has rolled out a new scent called “Fresh Cut Grass” that comes in a golf-themed jar handmade by local artisan Amanda Lee.

Ms. Flanick and Ms. Lee collaborate around four times per year, often on seasonal scents. Their partnership is based on bartering — their collaborations are sold in both Amanda Lee Glassware and Oakmont Candle Works, so Ms. Lee sends dozens of glasses to Ms. Flanick and receives dozens of candles back.

Ms. Lee said she enjoys the camaraderie that comes with having another woman-owned small craft business in town.

“I love it,” she said. “I always have someone to talk to about how hard it is and how fun it is.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Flanick’s candles typically ring in at $1.65 to $1.85 per ounce to cover the costs of the containers, lids, fragrances, wicks, and wax; a large candle in a glass jar runs around $20.

Last December, Ms. Flanick reckoned she produced 4,600 candles, many of them bulk orders for events like weddings. One of her top repeat customers is Oakmont Bakery, she said, which has a custom scent resembling chocolate fudge cheesecake. The iconic bakery orders 150 to 500 candles at a time, Ms. Flanick said.

Today, Ms. Flanick’s roster of full-time employees remains “me, myself, and I,” she said, with help as needed from her mother, Cindy, her Aunt Dell, her husband and children.

“I know that I can supply for my family and my kids in college, and kind of have a little backbone for whenever I want to retire,” Ms. Flanick said. “It’s just special – it makes me proud that I can say this is my shop and I built this.

“Not (everyone) made it through COVID, and I came out even better than I started.”