The state’s Commonwealth Court ruled that a fee imposed by the city on professional athletes and artists performing at publicly funded venues is unconstitutional, a significant win for prominent entertainers who have fought city officials for nearly five years.

Sometimes referred to as a “jock tax,” the fee absorbs 3% of income earned in Pittsburgh’s professional sports facilities, including PPG Paints Arena, PNC Park and Acrisure Stadium.

The appellate court’s 15-page opinion on Wednesday upheld a decision by Common Pleas Judge Christine Ward two years ago — she instituted an injunction preventing the city from collecting the 3% tax from athletes and entertainers who perform at those facilities. Wednesday’s decision keeps the injunction in place.

The case began in 2019, when three professional athletes — Scott Wilson, a former Pittsburgh Penguin; Kyle Palmieri, a right winger for the New York Islanders; and Major League Baseball outfielder Jeff Francoeur — sued the city to end the fee. The NFL, NHL and MLB players associations also joined in the suit.

Advertise with us

The three athletes said in court documents that they paid more than $25,000 in total to the city under the fee.

In September 2022, Judge Ward ruled in favor of the athletes, arguing that the tax placed a “discriminatory burden on out-of-state residents” and violates a clause of the state constitution that says “all taxes shall be uniform, upon the same class of subjects, within the territorial limits of the authority levying the tax.”

City officials appealed to Commonwealth Court, and the seven-judge panel heard oral arguments in October.

The judges rejected the city’s fee, saying it sets different rules for residents and nonresidents, which is unconstitutional. City attorneys argued there was no distinction — out-of-town athletes pay a 3% income tax, whereas local athletes pay a 2% school tax and 1% income tax.

Said the Commonwealth Court: “The city has failed to provide the requisite concrete justification for treating residents and nonresidents as distinguishable classes that may be subjected to different tax burdens.”

Advertise with us

City officials can appeal to the state supreme court, but it’s unclear whether they will.

Neena Hagen: nhagen@post-gazette.com