Gus Faucher is the senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He shares his insights on the regional economy each month.

The manufacturing industry in the Pittsburgh metropolitan area is recovering from the recession in 2021, as it is nationally. The initial improvement in 2020 came from businesses recalling workers laid off at the start of the pandemic. More recently, the industry’s expansion has come from stronger demand for manufactured goods as the U.S. and global economies recover from pandemic-induced recessions.

Manufacturing employment in the greater Pittsburgh area will continue to increase as the U.S. economy expands strongly in 2022, while not returning to its pre-pandemic level.

But eventually local manufacturing job growth will falter as U.S. consumer spending growth starts to shift from goods to services. And in a couple of years local manufacturing employment will return to its long-run downward trend due to shifts in spending patterns and improvements in technology.

Advertise with us

The good news is that those manufacturing jobs that remain in the Pittsburgh area will be very well-paying.

A decades-long trend

Manufacturing employment has been falling in the Pittsburgh area for decades. The biggest decline came in the early 1980s, when the local steel industry was devastated by high interest rates; two recessions, one quite severe; and lower-cost imports. Since then, local manufacturing employment has generally declined, albeit at a slower pace.

It did increase during the expansion of the late 1990s, and Pittsburgh-area manufacturing employment held steady in the expansion from 2010 to 2020, before the pandemic hit. Local manufacturing employment fell by about 10,000, or 12%, in early 2020 as the pandemic came to the United States and many businesses shut down. Local manufacturing has since added back about 4,000 of those jobs (see Chart).

Job growth in the recovery could have been even stronger, with very strong demand for manufactured goods from consumers and businesses as the economy has picked back up.

Advertise with us

But some older manufacturing workers decided to retire in the wake of the pandemic, hampering the recovery. Many local manufacturers who would like to hire are having difficulty in finding workers, especially for skilled positions. The manufacturing labor shortage is also a problem nationally, with more than 1 million unfilled positions in the industry as of October, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Strong demand

Local manufacturing employment is likely to increase in the near term as the U.S. economy generally, and manufacturing in particular, recover from the Viral Recession.

Demand for manufactured goods will remain strong through 2022. In aggregate U.S. consumers have a lot of money saved up from federal government economic stimulus efforts and limited opportunities to spend during the pandemic. Household spending on manufactured goods is especially strong, given that many consumers are still reluctant to go out in public and spend on services.

Demand for business investment goods is also solid; with the tight labor market, firms are buying equipment that allow their existing workforces to be more productive. And Pittsburgh-area exporters will benefit from stronger growth overseas as the pandemic gradually fades and foreign economies expand. A gradual easing of supply-chain problems in the months ahead will allow local manufacturers to expand output, although they will need to raise pay to attract workers.

Advertise with us

Still, over the longer run Pittsburgh-area manufacturing employment will continue its decades-long decline.

Much of this is inevitable. Over time American consumers have been spending more of their incomes on services, rather than goods. That process temporarily reversed with the pandemic, but as conditions revert to their pre-pandemic state, services will once again lead overall consumer spending growth.

The bigger reason for the long-run decline in manufacturing employment will be, as it has been in the past, increasing productivity.

With technological advances and automation, an average manufacturing worker now produces more than double what he or she did three decades ago. As a result, manufacturing output has increased even as industry employment has fallen.

A Pittsburgh opportunity

Advertise with us

Those manufacturing workers who have held onto their jobs, however, have received higher wages. Nationally over the past 20 years manufacturing wages have increased more rapidly than inflation. Increased imports have also led to the loss of manufacturing jobs for decades, particularly for low-cost goods using less-skilled labor that can be produced more cheaply overseas.

The manufacturing that has remained in the U.S. is increasingly concentrated in specialized goods that require workers with expert skills. And while overall manufacturing employment in the Pittsburgh area is set to gradually decline over time, local manufacturing will be increasingly concentrated in very well-paying industries where the region has a competitive advantage.

With Pittsburgh’s strength in industries such as robotics, healthcare, specialized metals, and chemicals, as well as access to inexpensive natural gas from the Marcellus Shale, those manufacturing jobs that do remain in the area will pay increasingly higher wages.

These jobs will require special skills, and local schools, colleges and universities, and employers will have to work together to make sure that the area is producing workers that can thrive in 21st century manufacturing. If they do, the manufacturing outlook for the Pittsburgh metropolitan area will be bright, even as overall industry employment gradually falls.