A federal appellate court has reversed a Pittsburgh judge's order granting a preliminary injunction requested by Teamsters Local 211 against the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in an attempt to preserve jobs and health care benefits.

U.S. District Judge J. Nicholas Ranjan in November granted a request for the injunction, ordering that the company maintain the workers' status quo while contract negotiations continue. The judge reissued another order clarifying the injunction in December.

The newspaper appealed to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which heard argument on March 3.

A three-judge panel ruled Wednesday that Judge Ranjan was wrong in finding that an "implied-in-fact contract existed [between the parties] and to issue a preliminary injunction maintaining the status quo regarding the CBA [collective bargaining agreement]."

Advertise with us

The union had requested the emergency relief after discovering that the paper planned to lay off 30 employees and remove health care coverage for 40 others shortly after Thanksgiving.

The Teamsters and the newspaper have been negotiating a new contract since January 2017. In September, according to Judge Ranjan's opinion, the newspaper gave the union a proposal that made changes to the collective bargaining agreement and the following month sent a letter concerning those changes, which included the layoffs, health care cuts and work schedule changes.

The two sides could not reach an agreement and the Teamsters filed a grievance on Nov. 6 with the National Labor Relations Board.

The circuit judges said that because the letter "achieved the requisite specificity necessary for extrication, and indeed manifested a clear, particularized disavowal of the CBA, there was no implied-in-fact contract between the parties after the CBA expired."

The judges said their job was to determine if the letter was ambiguous, "and as explained, we find that it was not."

The ruling vacates the injunction.