The fate of public sector unions seemed in peril just over a year ago, when the U.S. Supreme Court issued a long-anticipated decision making it illegal for unions to collect fees from government workers who choose not to join a union.
Before the court’s June 2018 ruling in Janus v. AFSCME, unions depended on the agency fees that they could collect from nonmembers who still benefited from collective bargaining agreements. The court ruled 5-4 that such agency fees violated the First Amendment by requiring members to help pay for political speech they might disagree with.
Some experts predicted the ruling would cause a mass exodus of members from unions representing millions of teachers, health workers and other government employees — devastating those unions’ finances.
“It was a really existential thing,” said Steve Catanese, president of Service Employees International Union (SEIU) Local 668 in Pittsburgh.
But one year out, union leaders around Pittsburgh say that they’re in good financial shape, and that membership has held steady or even ticked up a bit — although virtually all nonmembers have stopped paying agency fees. Leaders say this lesser-than-expected impact, which mirrors nationwide trends, is the result of months-long campaigns that they waged leading up to the ruling, efforts that were aimed at improving communication with members and convincing them to stay.
Mr. Catanese said SEIU 668’s membership of about 16,000 people — largely social service workers — has stayed mostly unchanged in the last year, though nearly all nonmembers have stopped paying fees as expected. Representatives from the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers and the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees confirmed that the Pittsburgh locals have also retained members while losing most or all fee-payers.
Read More
For months, Mr. Catanese said, he and other SEIU staff awaited the ruling with dread — confident that they’d prepared as well as they could, but ultimately uncertain what the impact would be.
When SEIU signed up more new members than they lost on the day of the decision, their preparation seemed to have paid off.
“It felt like we’d won something big on Super Bowl Sunday,” Mr. Catanese said. “We didn’t like the decision, but the response of the workers and willingness to stay with us and get more active — it was incredibly relieving.”
A wake-up call
Starting when he became president in January 2018, Mr. Catanese and other leaders began approaching members directly, explaining the upcoming case and trying to establish a consensus that workers would be better off as dues-paying members. (Current dues for SEIU 668 are 1.39% of a worker’s salary, while agency fees were about half that total).
In the first half of 2018, leading up to the June 27 ruling, SEIU 668 saw its membership grow by at least 500.
Those efforts resemble approaches taken by other national unions, who treated the Janus case as a wake-up call to ramp up engagement with members, said Paul Clark, director of Penn State University's School of Labor and Employment Relations. Membership in nationwide public sector unions often numbers in the millions, and leaders haven’t always managed to carry their messages down to the rank-and-file.
“When you have large organizations like that, communicating with individual members on a regular basis becomes a real challenge,” said Mr. Clark, who has consulted for public sector unions in the past.
While leaders are busy negotiating contracts with employers, “It’s easy to put engaging and communicating with members on the back burner,” he said.
Mr. Catanese said his union is financially healthy, despite the loss of more than 2,500 fee-payers.
“Frankly, we did lose money — agency fees were a big portion of our budget,” he said. “But when we saw more people join up, it replaced a lot of that loss.”
Facebook becomes a new front
The Janus ruling also escalated a political fight that is still in its early stages. Conservative groups in Pennsylvania that celebrated the ruling have stepped up their advocacy against public sector unions, contending that it will take time for the decision’s full impact to be felt.
Much of that action has taken place in federal courts, where legal groups like the Harrisburg-based Fairness Center have filed a flurry of lawsuits seeking to block union elections and make it easier for members to leave a union.
Meanwhile, the Commonwealth Foundation, a conservative think tank also based in Harrisburg, has advocated for state bills that would require public employers to remind workers that union membership is voluntary.
Commonwealth CEO Charles Mitchell argued that union membership hasn’t dropped since Janus because workers haven’t yet been made aware of the ruling’s implications.
“The laws and everything that govern public sector unions are very complicated,” he said. “It takes time for people to understand their rights, and the people who are best educated about it are the leaders of the public sector unions.”
To spread the word about Janus, conservative groups have made use of online advertisements targeted at public sector workers. In the last year, the Harrisburg-based outreach group Americans for Fair Treatment, which has ties to the Commonwealth Foundation, has spent thousands of dollars on Facebook ads portraying teachers unions in a negative light.
One advertisement, which ran in Pennsylvania from July 16-22, states, “Less than 5% of the union dues teachers pay stay with their local union. The rest is sent off to the state and national organizations to pay for mostly executive salaries and administrative spending.” The ad reached between 10,000 and 50,000 people, according to Facebook’s online ad library.

Those claims are “absolutely ridiculous,” said Nina Esposito-Visgitis, president of the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers, who said many of her 3,000 members have gotten similar communications over Facebook and via direct mail.
The bulk of the PFT’s dues go to member programming, Ms. Esposito-Visgitis said. She added that the union’s political activity — the issue at the heart of the Janus case — is “totally separate from membership dues,” with members paying a separate, refundable $10 fee that goes toward the union’s political action committee.
And union leaders say they’ve been open with their members about the implications of the Janus ruling, disputing the argument put forth by the Commonwealth Foundation that rank-and-file members have been kept in the dark.
“I always think knowledge is power,” Ms. Esposito-Visgitis said.
Looking ahead, Mr. Catanese said it’s fair to wonder whether today’s relative stability might give way within the next decade if more workers become aware of the court ruling and decide their union dues aren’t worth the price.
“It’s going to be indicative of how hard we keep working, how much we stay in touch with our membership,” he said.
“I think we can do it, I think we will do it, but time will tell.”
Nick Garber: ngarber@post-gazette.com.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.