WASHINGTON — The U.S. Department of Education has repealed a rule that the Obama administration saw as a key effort to protect students at for-profit career schools: the gainful employment rule, which penalized college programs that produced too many graduates with unmanageable student loan debt.
For-profit education giants, like Pittsburgh-based Education Management Corp., blamed that rule for their financial struggles.
When the gainful employment rule was finalized in July 2015, the Obama administration called it “a signature effort to protect students and taxpayers” because it would “end the flow of federal student aid to career training programs that leave students buried in debt with few opportunities to repay it.”
The rule tied federal funding for college programs to minimum standards of debt-to-income rates of their graduates.
It was among a spate of regulations imposed after federal investigations into the for-profit education industry, including a probe into EDMC’s recruiting practices.
Yet it was harshly criticized by the career schools, many of which could not meet the thresholds. The first gainful employment ratings released in 2017 showed 98% of programs that failed the standards were operated by for-profit institutions.
Read More
EDMC, the corporate owner of the Art Institutes and three other nationwide college chains, was at its peak when the U.S. Department of Justice and attorneys general from 39 states and the District of Columbia began investigating claims the company had paid incentives to recruiters based on the number of students they enrolled.
In November 2015, EDMC paid about $100 million to settle those allegations, admitting no wrongdoing.
But EDMC’s enrollment had already fallen dramatically amid the public scrutiny.
The company shuttered schools and laid off faculty and staff. It eventually sold the storied Art Institute chain in 2017, but the new nonprofit owners, Dream Center Education Holdings, could not manage it. Virtually all the former EDMC schools have now shut down. Last year, EDMC began liquidating in Chapter 7 bankruptcy.
The company’s leadership placed the blame squarely with the Obama education department. In a 2015 Post-Gazette interview after the gainful employment rule went into effect, Mark McEachen, then the EDMC CEO, cast it as unfairly targeting for-profit schools and an “overcorrection” by regulators to problems found at other schools.
The rule’s repeal played out in slow motion over two years, after Education Secretary Betsy DeVos pledged to remove it as one of her first official acts. She was appointed by President Donald Trump.
After receiving tens of thousands of comments and some bureaucratic delays, the department announced a final repeal action on Friday. The rule was gone as of Monday.
Student loan protection groups expressed outrage.
“Students need protection against unaffordable loans,” read a statement from The Institute for College Access and Success, a nonprofit co-founded by a former Obama administration education official. “At a time when millions of borrowers are struggling with debts they cannot afford, the department's repeal of the gainful employment rule is reckless and irresponsible.”
The Oakland, Calif.-based advocacy group highlighted the department’s plan to spend an estimated $6.2 billion over the next 10 years on grants and loans for programs that were previously disqualified from federal aid — or, as the group described them, “costly, low-value programs” that it said “cost students billions more in lost wages and higher loan payments.”
Meanwhile, industry trade groups applauded the move.
Steve Gunderson, president and CEO of Career Education Colleges and Universities, based in Arlington, Va., called the department’s repeal a move away from “picking and choosing winners and losers in higher education.”
“This standard is universally fair and applies to all students, in all programs, at all schools, regardless of sector — something that previous administrations did not do,” he said in a statement.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, Twitter @PGdanielmoore




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.