After Alcoa split into two companies in 2016, the firm carrying the historic Pittsburgh aluminum company’s name has largely avoided much of the high-profile drama playing out at the other one.
Arconic, now a New York-based manufacturer of products for the aerospace, automotive and other industries, has been roiled by battles with activist shareholders that led to a year of cost-cutting — including laying off 100 research employees in Upper Burrell, Westmoreland County, in April. Arconic announced this year it will split itself again.
Meanwhile, Alcoa, the largest U.S. producer of aluminum, has quietly worked to strengthen its balance sheet and shield its business from the inevitable rise and fall of commodity prices.
Yet, comparing the two companies, investors in Alcoa’s stock have been far less pleased. Alcoa’s stock lost more than half its value over the past year, while Arconic is up 25% in the same time period.
Meanwhile, concerns over slowing demand, the prospect of a prolonged trade war with China and a 16-month labor dispute at its Quebec plant spilled over on Wednesday at the Alcoa annual shareholders meeting, held at the Hotel Fairmont Pittsburgh, Downtown.
At the meeting, which was streamed online but closed to media, CEO Roy Harvey sought to reassure investors that the company was working to improve what it can control: to operate simply and more efficiently.
Read More
“We are always looking to reduce complexity,” Mr. Harvey said.
“We’ve come into 2019 stronger but with a clear-sighted view of what we can do to make this company even better,” he added. “However, we’re faced with an environment that is very different from last year ... 2018 is fundamentally different from 2019.”
The company’s challenges come from the market, regulatory and labor issues.
Tariffs on imports of aluminum from Canada are also weighing on Alcoa’s three Canadian facilities.
About 28% of Alcoa’s aluminum is produced in plants in Canada, according to Bloomberg Intelligence data, so it costs the company more to bring the metal into the United States under the Trump administration’s tariffs.
Alcoa has requested an exclusion from the 10% tariffs on Canadian aluminum imports imposed in March 2018. The U.S. Department of Commerce has not issued a decision.
Negotiations to end the U.S.-China trade war have recently faltered. Last weekend, President Donald Trump threatened to raise tariffs on more Chinese imports this Friday if a deal is not reached. Alcoa’s stock opened on Monday down nearly 3%.
Meanwhile, a protracted labor dispute at its Quebec smelter has only made things worse. In January 2018, Alcoa locked out about 1,100 hourly union workers represented by the United Steelworkers as negotiations for a new labor deal fell apart.
On Wednesday, about 150 workers at the Aluminerie de Bécancour Inc. smelter, who were bused from Quebec, gathered at the USW headquarters Downtown.
Blowing noisemakers, the workers marched to the Fairmont to protest the shareholders meeting, disrupting traffic and creating a spectacle for people heading to work.
The workers gathered “to pass a message to the shareholder that this lockout has to stop,” said Daniel Mallette, a USW member, in between chants and songs. “It’s an immoral lockout.”
In December, Alcoa announced it would cut production by half at the smelter’s last remaining production line. The lockout shuttered the facility’s two other production lines and dropped the plant’s capacity from 413,000 metric tons a year to 138,000 metric tons a year.
The smelter’s salaried employees have stepped in to operate the production line, but “recent retirements and departures” required the plant to scale back even more, the company said in December.
On Wednesday, an Alcoa spokesperson said the company has negotiated in good faith, participating in more than 50 mediation sessions since May 2018. The smelter “must make fundamental changes for its long-term viability, productivity and global competitiveness,” the spokesperson said in a statement.
The market outlook is also a question.
In April, Alcoa revised down its expectation for global aluminum demand growth in 2019. It now expects demand to grow between 2% and 3%, down from between 3% and 4% expected in the previous quarter, “predominantly due to lower demand growth in China, especially in the transportation and electrical sectors,” the company stated.
That growth would be slower than the 4% seen in 2018 and the slowest demand growth rate in a decade.
Falling alumina and aluminum prices have eroded Alcoa’s earnings. In the first quarter, Alcoa reported a net less of $199 million, or $1.07 per share, compared with a profit of $195 million, or $1.04 a share, in the first quarter of 2018.
Revenue slumped to $2.7 billion in the first quarter, down from $3.1 billion the year-ago quarter, which Alcoa executives attributed to falling prices and not a drop in production.
“We’re frustrated with where prices sit,” Mr. Harvey said during the meeting.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.
This story was updated at 11:24 a.m. on May 8, 2019.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.