When his pitching career with the Montreal Expos was cut short in 1976 because of back and shoulder injuries, Chip Lang knew he had not played in Major League Baseball long enough to qualify for a pension. He accepted that, and moved on with his life.

“I understood at that time that you needed four years of service time to qualify for a pension and I didn’t qualify,” he said. “So really, there was no question in my mind as to whether I should or shouldn’t. I didn’t.”

That changed in April 2011 when Major League Baseball and the players union — the Major League Baseball Players Association — announced that non-vested players who left the league before 1980 would each receive up to $10,000 in annual non-qualified retirement payments for having played the game they love.

Mr. Lang, 65, who now works as a self-employed employee benefits consultant for Hager Wang Settina in Franklin Park, received his first Major League Baseball pension check for $1,875 the following February. He has received one each February since.

Advertise with us

Major league baseball players are a small and elite fraternity. From the year the league was founded to the present, there have only been 18,801 of them, according to Baseball-Reference.com.

In today’s game, players earn between $400,000 and $32 million. They earn lifetime health benefits after playing only one day in the league and they qualify for a pension after only 43 game days.

But the men who played between 1947 and 1980 worked under a different deal. Those are the men spotlighted by author Doug Gladstone in his self-published 2010 book titled “A Bitter Cup of Coffee: How MLB and The Players Association Threw 874 Retirees a Curve.”

When the pension fund was established in April 1947, players were required to accrue five years of service credit in order to qualify for it. That threshold was lowered to four years in 1969.

A photo of Chip Lang in his playing days with the Montreal Expos hangs in his Wexford Office in Pine Township. Chip Lang is one of several retired major league baseball players who for many years were denied a pension because they had played less than five years in the big leagues. Now Mr. Lang has begun receiving an annual pension check of $1,875. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Eleven years later, during the 1980 Memorial Day weekend, a threatened players’ walkout was averted when the league and the union agreed players would be eligible for a pension after playing roughly one quarter of a season.

Advertise with us

The agreement was not made retroactive for players who left the major leagues before 1980.

By the time the agreement to provide a non-qualified retirement payment to pre-1980 players was reached in 2011, there weren’t a lot of them left. Mr. Gladstone said close to 900 men benefited from the 2011 agreement. Today there are about 500 left.

“Every time a man dies, the payment dies with him,” said Mr. Gladstone of Albany, N.Y. “It’s not a real pension. Typically if you are a vested retiree with a pension, wives get it when you die. But in this case, that money stops when they do.”

Pre-1980 players receive no health benefits from the deal.

The Players Association is not legally obligated to represent those who played between 1947 and 1979. The agreement reached by MLB and the players union in 1980 only includes players from that point on.

Advertise with us

Four quarters = $2,500

The benefits package Major League Baseball offers today’s players is a far cry from the early years, according to an article in the spring issue of the New York State Bar Association’s Entertainment, Arts and Sports Law Journal.

The new five-year agreement that runs through 2021 raises the minimum salary of MLB players to $555,000 by 2019. Today’s players also can receive a pension of up to $210,000 based on their salary and number of years in the league. Pensions also can be passed on to a widowed spouse or other designated beneficiary.

According to a Forbes magazine report in June, the current MLB Players’ pension and welfare fund is valued at $2.7 billion.

Under the 2011 agreement, non-qualified pension payments are based on a formula that awards players $625 for every quarter of service the former baseball players accrued.

Advertise with us

Four quarters — one year — equals $2,500 annually. Sixteen quarters amounts to the maximum payment of $10,000.

Mr. Lang played for a part of three seasons in 1974, 1975 and 1976, which is why he receives $1,875 annually.

“Major League Baseball didn’t have to do anything for any of us because that was not the rules back then,” he said. “I think it was very nice of them to do it. I’m appreciative of getting that $1,875 every year because it’s found money.”

Chip Lang talks about the shrinking pool of eligible major league players for the annual pension. Mr. played for the Montreal Expos, is one of several retired major league baseball players who for many years were denied a pension because they had played less than five years in the big leagues. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

He has done well enough after baseball that he doesn’t need the money to pay the bills, but he knows that not everyone is in the same situation. And it bothers him that some players missed out entirely on the deal made at least 30 years after they had left the diamond.

“There are guys that passed away over the last 25 or 30 years and got nothing because they didn’t make it to 2011. They didn’t have the time to wait to get it.

Advertise with us

“And that group of 700 or 800 people is getting less and less every year. There are some guys who could have used the money. There are guys who would have welcomed a check.”

Greg Bouris, spokesman for the Major League Baseball Players Association in New York, declined to comment other than to say that since 2011, the union has negotiated more than $30 million in benefits for non-vested players who otherwise were receiving nothing.

Torn ligaments

The most money Bob Sadowski ever made in a single year playing Major League Baseball from 1963 to 1966 was $17,000.

The Lawrenceville native who now lives in Sharpsburg, Ga., pitched in the majors for Milwaukee for three years and was traded to Boston in 1966. He tore ligaments in his arm and neck just shy of the four-year mark, which ended his baseball career.

Advertise with us

Mr. Sadowski holds the distinction of being the last pitcher to toe the rubber for the Milwaukee Braves before the team moved to Atlanta in 1967.

Two of his brothers also played in the major leagues. Ed Sadowski went to the Boston Red Sox and ended up with the Milwaukee Braves as a catcher. Another brother, Ted Sadowski, was picked up by the Washington Senators.

Ed died of Lou Gehrig’s disease. Ted died of cancer. Neither of them played long enough to qualify for a pension or health benefits from the big league.

For many years Mr. Sadowski, 79, thought he qualified for pension and health benefits. He was crushed when he discovered that baseball did not give him full credit for his incomplete year with Boston.

Because of the change in 2011, he now collects a $7,000 check each February.

Advertise with us

“I am grateful for the opportunity to play in the majors,” Mr. Sadowski said. “I’m not bitter. I loved signing autographs.”

He doesn’t go to games much anymore and doesn’t understand an era when some players who are paid millions don’t sign autographs for the fans.

“I’ve been sick. I beat death,” he said. “But my bills are pretty high. I could have used some help. They can’t say they don’t have it. I’m not jealous. I just want my share. Whenever I have to call up there for whatever reason [to the main office], I tell them I’m thankful. It’s not much. But it’s something for me.”

Retirees are responsible for paying their own taxes on the retirement check.

Mr. Gladstone said he believes his book may have played a role in turning a spotlight on how pre-1980 players were denied pension benefits. He received coverage in national newspapers such as the New York Times, the Los Angeles Times, as well as on talk radio.

Advertise with us

“These men are being penalized for playing ball at the wrong time through no fault of their own,” he said.

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.