A federal jury has rejected a sex discrimination claim brought by a former forensic investigator at the Allegheny County Medical Examiner's Office following an eight-day trial in U.S. District Court.

Kelly Vay had sued the county and four current and former administrators in 2014, saying they created a hostile work environment for her and other female workers.

Among her claims was that men in the office used a vulgar term to refer to a group of women there and that supervisors tolerated sexist behavior by males and retaliated against Ms. Vay after she complained.

But on Tuesday an eight-person jury ruled in favor of the supervisors on all claims.

Advertise with us

Ms. Vay's lawyer, Michael Lorence, declined to comment because Ms. Vay has a second suit pending in federal court in which she says managers retaliated against her after stories critical of the medical examiner's office appeared in the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review in 2013.

Lawyers for the county did not respond to a request for comment.

Ms. Vay, 36, of North Versailles, was hired in 2009 and fired in 2014. She had numerous run-ins with supervisors in those five years.

In her suit, she named former chief administrator Stephen Pilarski; Robert Huston, the lab director; Michael Baker, the former manager of morgue operations; and Michael Chichwak, manager of investigations.

She claimed in her initial complaint and at trial that she was singled out for discipline multiple times for various infractions, such as swearing at supervisors, that male investigators also committed without similar repercussions.

Advertise with us

Her disciplinary record includes a five-day suspension for an incident in which she and another female investigator left a body in their van while they stopped at Walmart. She said they were using the bathroom, although the county said they were shopping.

At trial, county lawyers also presented a binder of internet activity for a county computer that Ms. Vay used to bolster the defense claim that she shopped online on county time.

The managers denied that they treated her differently than the men or that they retaliated against her.

The second lawsuit, filed in 2015, pertains to a First Amendment claim.

Ms. Vay was the spokeswoman for a group of investigators who sent letters to County Executive Rich Fitzgerald in 2013, the first complaining about working conditions and poor management and a second saying the office wasn't doing enough autopsies.

Advertise with us

After those letters were given to the Tribune Review and stories appeared, Ms. Vay said she was targeted for retaliation in violation of her right to free speech.

That case is pending before U.S. District Judge Nora Barry Fischer.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.