A Downtown building owner has decided to drop its unionized security contractor, a move that could have consequences for a citywide contract approved last year.

Full-time security guards covered by the citywide contract — which covers hundreds of security guards who patrol dozens of large commercial buildings — are set to, for the first time, receive employer-provided health care plans on Jan. 1.

The contract, bargained over several months by the Service Employees International Union with close to a dozen security contractors, was championed by city officials as the biggest labor victory in Pittsburgh in a decade. In a ceremony announcing the agreement in October 2015, Mayor Bill Peduto credited it with “literally rebuilding the middle class.”

But the property owner of PNC Center, a building at 20 Stanwix St., informed one of the contractors involved in the citywide agreement that it would be moving forward with another security provider beginning in January.

Advertise with us

Douglas Bell, general manager for M&J Wilkow, Ltd., the Chicago-based owner of PNC Center, told Kellington Protection in an email on Dec. 13 that the building would source its security from OSS Inc., a contractor based in Warren, Ohio.

Guards supplied by OSS Inc. will be under a union contract bargained by the Teamsters, wrote Darcy Rutzen, vice president for marketing for M&J Wilkow, in an email. OSS Inc. could not be reached for comment.

“20 Stanwix continues to support and maintain a union workforce,” Ms. Rutzen wrote. “The move is a decision based on our continuous evaluation of contract providers in order to best meet the needs of the building and its tenants.”

While the property at 20 Stanwix, which has about eight guards, is a relatively small loss for Kellington Protection, the move could undermine the citywide agreement if other building owners follow suit, said Ralph Bergin, a vice president at Kellington.

That contract put major security agencies on a level playing field when it came to wages and health care, Mr. Bergin said, so they could compete based on quality of service — “which is how it should be for security,” he added.

Advertise with us

“If companies bidding out security services are placing their emphasis on cost, we cannot compete,” Mr. Bergin said.

Sam Williamson, Western Pennsylvania area director for 32BJ SEIU, the local chapter of the property services labor union, said he has opened a “dialogue” with Mr. Bell.

He said the move is a rare exception to building owners’ attitudes toward the agreement. While nothing prohibits them from switching to other union or non-union workers, he doesn’t expect other building owners to follow suit.

The citywide contract, which runs through 2018, boosts hourly wages for guards by $1.95 to $11.75 over the course of the three-year contract.

Earlier this month, Kellington had sent out an email reminding its clients — which, in addition to PNC Center, include the Oliver Building, the Grant Building, the Heinz 57 Building and the Smithfield Building — about health care costs required by the labor agreement set to take effect next month.

Advertise with us

Kellington, a Carnegie security provider that merged with International Investigative Services earlier this year, also has non-union guards in smaller buildings, including at the Post-Gazette’s buildings in Downtown and Clinton. Kellington employs about 80 guards total.

The emailed message laid out Kellington’s plan: Costs would be passed through to building owners for health care coverage available to full-time employees working at least 30 hours a week, and the costs to building owners could not exceed $426 a month for each covered employee.

Six days later, Mr. Bell responded by email, notifying Kellington it would be moving forward with another provider and citing the cost of insurance as a factor.

One stipulation of the contract — a city law that security contractors must pay for training for their guards — is currently being challenged in court by a building owners’ trade association.

Though most guards receive basic training in skills such as CPR and use of a heart defibrillator, the SEIU argued they need training on more skills to handle emergencies of all sorts. The security guards do not carry weapons.

Advertise with us

Mr. Bergin said he knows the guards are sometimes not taken seriously, being portrayed as the butt of jokes in movies and television shows.

“It has been proven many times over that they take their responsibilities very seriously, and that they are critically important when a crisis occurs,” he said. “To get the best, most reliable and most competent people filling those positions, you need to pay a decent wage and offer some important benefits.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.