Ah, spring. If you can see the outside world through the window of your office, you might be looking wistfully at the trees outside and wishing to breathe in the breeze that sways them.

But you’re in a modern office building. Your windows don’t open.

You can’t be trusted.

Left to your own devices, you’d probably throw open the windows on a hot day and leave them open all night long, forcing the air conditioner to compensate for your recklessness.

Advertise with us

You would wreak havoc on the carefully calibrated mechanical systems of your building.

You have no idea whether the air quality outside even warrants a breath of fresh air.

Since the 1970s, commercial buildings have been leaning toward taking atmospheric controls away from occupants for all those reasons.

“That pendulum has actually started to shift back in the past five years,” said Aurora Sharrard, executive director at the Green Building Alliance on the South Side. (Her organization’s office — a converted refrigerator warehouse — doesn’t have operable windows. “We considered it,” she said).

Building designers, especially those focused on sustainability, are paying more attention, not just to the benefits of natural ventilation but to the occupants’ desire for control of their own environment.

Advertise with us

“I think one of the biggest arguments today is that there is actually a market shift — that people really love the idea of being sort of half outdoors,” said Vivian Loftness, a professor of architecture at Carnegie Mellon University.

Think about the restaurants that swap their brick facades for glass garage doors.

Or look at the latest, greenest building in Pittsburgh — PNC Tower. The 33-story structure has been dubbed a “breathing building” for its operable windows that circulate fresh air throughout the working space.

But as John Robinson, director of development, design-build at P.J. Dick Inc. who worked on the project noted, PNC’s windows open when conditions are right — when air quality, temperature and humidity all align to a quotient pre-programmed by the company.

The second “skin” at PNC Tower opens long rectangular windows to let air in while slots in the inner skin in the interior of the building allow that air to travel through the working spaces. For some measure of occupant control, PNC Tower has a “good day” indicator — a green light on the ceiling that tells people when they can slide open the doors that lead to the lobby between the interior and exterior surfaces.

Advertise with us

For buildings without pre-programmed windows, the indicator is crucial, Mr. Robinson said. Without that guidance, operable windows will likely waste more energy than they save and end up creating an uneven and uncomfortable environment for neighboring employees.

“If you’re going to do it, you better be able to tell your occupants when they can and when they should not have the windows open,” Mr. Robinson said. “If you don’t tell when, they end up having them open more than they should.”

Some buildings communicate that through smartphone apps. Others have something akin to a traffic light. If it’s red, keep them closed. If it’s green, open them up.

Phipps’ Center for Sustainable Landscapes takes a hybrid approach. Built to the standard of the Living Buildings Challenge meant to encourage sustainable structures, the space is required to have operable windows in each occupied room. The top windows in each space open automatically when conditions warrant.

“That is a signal to staff that they can open the lower ones close to them if they choose,” said Rich Piacentini, Phipp’s CEO. “We believe it is important for staff to have the option and be engaged in the process. It is one of the best features of the building.”

Advertise with us

If someone leaves the lower window open when it shouldn’t be, everyone at Phipps gets an e-mail telling them to close their windows and the building’s heating and cooling system won’t kick on until they do.

For Ms. Loftness, that’s proof that “it’s not difficult to control people’s behavior,”

“There’s no excuse not to let people open the window when they feel like it,” she said.

As for the air quality arguments, especially in a city like Pittsburgh that is downwind of industrial and power plants, she noted the question may raised: “How effective are the mechanical systems at filtering the fine particulates?”

Not very, she said. “On a bad (air) day, your mechanical system is delivering bad air to you.”

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.