About two-thirds of the region's charitable organizations have responded to Allegheny County's request to prove they deserve their property tax breaks -- but many, including UPMC, say they need more time.
So far, 2,084 organizations have answered the county's letter, which asked for documentation showing how they meet Pennsylvania's five-part test for a public charity. Of those, 1,340 gave justifications for why they should remain tax-exempt and 744 asked for more time.
The county launched the review of all tax-exempt properties earlier this year, finally fulfilling a statutory requirement to double-check its charity rolls every three years.
The largest nonprofit to respond is the University of Pittsburgh, which told the county it qualifies under the "public property for public purposes" tax exemption, not the exemption for a charitable institution. If the county believes otherwise, the university asked for more time to supply paperwork.
Many other colleges and universities in the county -- including Point Park, Chatham and Robert Morris -- also have responded to the county.
But others, including Carnegie Mellon and Duquesne, have asked for more time. They're joined by a broad cross section of nonprofits, ranging from hospitals to schools to the Sisters of the Third Order.
The elephant in this room is UPMC, which has more than 100 tax-free parcels. Spokeswoman Susan Manko said they're working on it but documenting the charitable mission of an organization of that size takes time.
"UPMC is diligently working to respond to each of the approximately 165 letters received from the County," she wrote in a statement.
The city of Pittsburgh has launched a challenge against the UPMC's nonprofit status, filing an administrative appeal with the county and a lawsuit in court. UPMC is the largest property owner in Allegheny County and pays taxes on only a portion of its properties.
UPMC wasn't alone in requesting an extension -- so did Allegheny General Hospital and a slew of other medical facilities across the county. County solicitor Andrew Szefi said his staff has tried to be accommodating, granting 30- and 60-day extensions when requested.
"The hurdle to get an extension was not to prove a hardship," Mr. Szefi said. "If we got a good faith request, we gave them more time."
A total of 704 organizations that have yet to mail any response at all received a second letter from the county giving them another 30 days to respond.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.