Monday, May 19, 2025, 12:26PM | 
MENU
Advertisement

TechMan: Website refines thinking on robots

TechMan: Website refines thinking on robots

In the 1920 science fiction play "R.U.R." by Czech playwright Karel Capek, robots created by the Rossum's Universal Robots Co. take over the world. The play introduced the word "robot" into the vocabulary, and since then the imagination has run wild about machine people.

A group of scientists, including two from Carnegie Mellon University, would like to help people refine their thinking about robotics beyond what they get in the popular press.

They have started robotradar.org, a website where scientists can comment on media stories about robots.

Advertisement

"Robohype is a real problem," said one of the website's founders, Alan Winfield, professor of electronic engineering, University of the West of England Bristol. "People reading the mainstream press could be forgiven for thinking that present day robots are capable of human reasoning, have feelings or behave ethically."

Another of the site's founding group, Illah Nourbakhsh, a CMU professor of robotics, got to meet a lot of Europeans in the field of robotics while on a sabbatical in England. "They were seeing more and more where science fiction about robots and reality collide," he said.

Matthew Mason, director of CMU's Robotics Institute, also scours the press for stories about robots and robotics.

Even though postings are written by experts, they try to keep the articles accessible and interesting.

Advertisement

For example, Mr. Nourbakhsh posted a reply to an article in The Wall Street Journal titled "Could We Trust Killer Robots?" about the possibility of robot soldiers.

In response to the idea that robots could one day make better soldiers than humans, Mr. Nourbakhsh wrote, "The draw is attractive: cold, calculating robots that are not susceptible to emotional sway will make lethal decisions that are highly rational and rule-based, following the letter of the law set down for them.

"This vision of rationality in war works particularly well if we imagine war to be a predictable, rule-governed practice, like a game of chess. But, unfortunately, war also has a chaotic, randomized and surprise-filled side to it, more like poker than chess."

He goes on to give four reasons that he thinks autonomous, lethal robots are a long way off.

"People think that a robot can be a soldier, but it is just a tool -- a weapon not a soldier. It will not have the decision-making ability that a soldier has."

Mr. Nourbakhsh thinks the biggest misconception the general public has about robots is that, "People think robots are more advanced than they are."

He thinks as robots become more commonplace, their most important contribution in the near term will be in improving people's quality of life: "Giving elderly people more mobility, allowing paraplegics to walk."

Along with robots will come ethical questions.

"They will accentuate the gap between rich and poor. Robots are going to be expensive for a long time," Mr. Nourbakhsh said. "What about when certain soldiers don't get prosthetic limbs when the government runs short of money?"

There also is the issue of robots competing with the poor for low-wage jobs.

The first step in coping with these issues is to give people accurate information about robots and distinguish between "what is feasible and what is possible."

So the next time you think about robots' future, don't think about Gort or "Danger, Will Robinson." Think about a robotic prosthetic arm or an intelligent wheelchair that can help your grandparent get around.

First Published: December 16, 2012, 5:00 a.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Canada's Sidney Crosby and Marc-Andre Fleury celebrating after winning the IIHF Ice Hockey World Championship group A match between Latvia and Canada at Avicii Arena in Stockholm, Sweden, Sunday, May 11, 2025.
1
sports
Jason Mackey: Enjoy one final run of Sidney Crosby and Marc-Andre Fleury — because they sure are
PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA - MAY 18: Bryson Stott #5 of the Philadelphia Phillies tags out Isiah Kiner-Falefa #7 of the Pittsburgh Pirates on an attempted steal in the fifth inning during a game at Citizens Bank Park on May 18, 2025 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The Phillies won 1-0. (Photo by Hunter Martin/Getty Images)
2
sports
3 takeaways: Paul Skenes 'deserved to win,' but Pirates shut out yet again
Mayor Ed Gainey and challenger Corey O'Connor
3
news
Pittsburgh at a tipping point in high-stakes race for mayor
Jared Jones #37 of the Pittsburgh Pirates delivers a pitch in the first inning during the game against the Minnesota Twins at PNC Park on June 9, 2024 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
4
sports
Pirates pitcher Jared Jones facing possible elbow surgery
5
news
Two competitive races could shape Allegheny County Council’s future
Advertisement
LATEST business
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story