Buncher Co. doesn't want or need a $50 million financing plan for its proposed Strip District project, Councilman Patrick Dowd said in a letter Monday, claiming that officials would spend up to $40 million of the funding pot on other projects with no accountability.
Mr. Dowd said the financing initiative would become a development "slush fund," an accusation that brought a sharp rebuke from Yarone Zober, chairman of the Urban Redevelopment Authority and chief of staff to Mayor Luke Ravenstahl.
Mr. Dowd and others have been complaining about a lack of details about Buncher's project and how it might relate to other city projects.
"He's a failed mayoral candidate whose posturing and politics pre-empt progress," Mr. Zober said of Mr. Dowd, who ran for mayor in 2009.
For the eighth week, Mr. Dowd declined Tuesday to introduce legislation that would create the tax-increment financing plan for Buncher's Riverfront Landing development, which would stretch from the Veterans Bridge to 21st Street between Smallman Street and the Allegheny River. Mr. Dowd controls the legislation, which involves the URA, as chairman of council's committee on intergovernmental affairs.
Under the financing plan, up to $50 million of Buncher real-estate taxes would be earmarked for public infrastructure improvements at the mixed-use development. Uses would include street, riverfront and aesthetic improvements.
Mr. Dowd had complained that the URA provided him details only on how about $10 million of the $50 million would be spent. He had demanded a breakdown of other uses for the money, though the URA said it wasn't possible to provide that level of detail for a project that could yield $400 million in investment over 10 to 15 years.
In a letter Monday to the mayor, Mr. Dowd raised new objections, saying Buncher told him that it didn't want and never asked for a $50 million financing plan. The company "made it absolutely clear that the figure of $50 million came from your employees and appointees, not Buncher," the letter said.
Indeed, Buncher said it would be hard pressed to use $15 million, Mr. Dowd's letter said.
Buncher could not be reached for comment.
Mr. Zober said it was "morally bankrupt" of Mr. Dowd to question the motives of URA officials, especially state Sen. Jim Ferlo, D-Highland Park. Mr. Ferlo's Senate district includes the Strip District, and he is a member of the URA board.
Robert Rubinstein, the URA's acting executive director, said financing plan proceeds can be used only in and immediately around the project site. He said funds couldn't be used for projects outside the TIF district.
Mr. Dowd also criticized city and URA officials for advocating the financing plan amid a property dispute between Buncher and Allegheny Valley Railroad, which claims an easement across the project site. Until that dispute is resolved, he said, the city and URA "have no power" to adopt a financing plan.
Mr. Rubinstein had a different interpretation, saying properties can be included in a financing plan district without the owners' consent. He said that's happened in TIF districts elsewhere in the city.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.