Pittsburgh City Councilman Patrick Dowd said he will hold up legislation for Buncher Co.'s proposed Strip District project until Mayor Luke Ravenstahl provides details on the "interlocking agreements and obligations" related to the development, including any generous real estate deals in the offering and the possible relocation of city employees to leased space in a new Buncher building.
"The redevelopment of the land along the Allegheny River has the potential to be one of Pittsburgh's greatest success stories. However, before discussing the merits of the plan, we have to know the plan itself," Mr. Dowd said Tuesday in a letter to the mayor.
However, Mr. Ravenstahl's office and the city Urban Redevelopment Authority accused Mr. Dowd of needlessly delaying a project that could generate as much as $500 million in investment over 10 to 15 years.
"We're partnering with the public and private sectors to get projects off the ground, create more jobs and capitalize on the momentum happening in Pittsburgh," mayoral spokeswoman Joanna Doven said.
For the second week in a row, Mr. Dowd, chairman of council's Intergovernmental Affairs Committee, declined to introduce a package of bills that would create a tax-increment financing plan of up to $50 million for Buncher, which has proposed retail, offices and more than 750 units of housing on a 55-acre tract stretching from the Veterans Bridge to 21st Street and Smallman Street to the Allegheny River. The project would mean razing about one-third of the historic produce terminal so that 17th Street could be extended from Smallman to the river.
Officials have given Buncher an option to purchase the terminal for $1.2 million, and the company would have to renovate the building within 24 months, according to Mr. Dowd's letter. Buncher plans to construct an office building at 13th Street, and the company has "tentative agreements with the city and some of its authorities to lease this space," Mr. Dowd said in the letter, citing information given to him by unnamed sources.
"Any lease discussions between Buncher and the city and its authorities should be revealed to the council and the public," Mr. Dowd's letter said.
Buncher did not return phone calls seeking comment.
Robert Rubinstein, the authority's acting executive director, said most of the details Mr. Dowd is seeking already have been provided at city planning commission meetings, authority board meetings and public meetings on Mr. Ravenstahl's vision for developing the Allegheny Riverfront. He noted that the planning commission next week will hold a public hearing on a zoning change needed for Buncher's project, which represents a significant piece of the overall riverfront improvement plans.
Mr. Rubinstein said the authority and other tenants of the authority-owned Robin Civic Building at 200 Ross will have to relocate if the building is to be sold for development.
Buncher's project already was controversial because of its potential impact on the landmark produce terminal and an environmental group's threatened federal lawsuit over stormwater-management issues. Mr. Dowd added a new dynamic with his letter claiming that Mr. Ravenstahl wants council to approve a financing package without saying how the lion's share of money would be used and without disclosing terms of related real estate deals.
Mr. Dowd said he doesn't oppose Buncher's project or a financing plan per se but will hold the bills until Mr. Ravenstahl's provides the details needed for an informed vote.
He said he understands that once Buncher purchases the produce terminal, the Urban Redevelopment Authority will receive a 36-month option to purchase Buncher's distribution center, a 16-acre site between 43rd and 48th streets in Lawrenceville, for $8 million, or about $500,000 per acre. In addition, he said he has been told that Buncher would receive an option to purchase 16 of 22 acres the authority owns near the 62nd Street Bridge in Lawrenceville for $1 million, or less than $70,000 per acre.
"You must help us understand the interlocking agreements and obligations that you have negotiated on behalf of the public," Mr. Dowd told the mayor.
Mr. Dowd said he believes that Buncher would like to relocate its distribution center to the 62nd street site, the former Tippins International property. He said residents have complained about truck traffic and related problems at the current location.
Mr. Rubinstein said possible deals involving the distribution center and Tippins properties have been discussed at authority meetings. While Buncher's purchase of the produce terminal would trigger the authority's option on the distribution center site, he said, Buncher's purchase of the Tippins property would be separate.
He was unable to confirm the would-be sales prices cited by Mr. Dowd but said Buncher wouldn't be getting a sweetheart deal because the distribution center and Tippins properties have markedly different values. He said the authority would use the distribution center site to create a "green boulevard" as part of the overall riverfront improvement project.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.