The South Side Planning Forum voted Tuesday night to recommend a Neighborhood Improvement District to City Council.
The forum moved the meeting from its usual room in the Brashear Association to the cafeteria at UPMC South Side to accommodate more than 100 people who gathered mostly to voice opposition to the plan and the additional tax burden it would place on residents.
"The NID would be a distraction, another layer of bureaucracy that we have to deal with," said Mary Ellen Leigh, a South Side homeowner. "This tax will not go away; and don't kid yourself, it will grow every year."
A Neighborhood Improvement District is an area of special assessment, whose property owners have voted to pay extra -- based on the value of their properties -- for an enhancement of the public services they get, such as street cleaning and security.
The vote in favor of the NID now goes to District 3 Councilman Bruce Kraus, who will determine if he will bring it to City Council.
If it reaches the council, a legal process will begin that will include a plan mailed to every property owner within the proposed district, public meetings and a vote.
The district cannot be established if 40 percent of the property owners vote in opposition to it.
To date, 40 percent of residents have signed letters in opposition to the new tax, which were placed in a stack and held in front of each forum member at the meeting.
"Now instead of listening to 1,200 people with their opposition, they aren't going to listen to us at all," said Helena Wagner, a South Side property owner who was with a group passing out anti-NID stickers.
Many of the residents, such as Ms. Wagner, balked at the idea of paying another tax that feeds into a system to help for-profit businesses.
But others said the NID could provide a solution to the littered streets and crime from bar hoppers on the weekend.
"The NID is ready to step up and clean up and help with enforcement. What is your plan?" resident Wanda Jankoski asked of those against the NID.
Evan Stoddard, a South Side resident, said the NID is needed because the problems plaguing the neighborhood won't be solved through existing public services alone.
"I, for one, don't believe the city has the resources to help us out," he said.
The NID would apply to about 2,800 property owners from the railroad at Josephine Street to the Monongahela River, between Ninth and 29th streets, said Susie Puskar, neighborhood outreach coordinator for the NID.
Residents, who make up 35 percent of the property owners, would pay 15 percent of the total fees because they do not generate income and because the concerns behind the need for a NID stem largely from bar businesses.
The average resident payment per month would be $10, she said.
NIDs have become more popular vehicles to provide services that have been sacrificed by cuts in public spending, but the economic downturn also fuels opposition.
Daniel Murrer, vice president of RealSTATs, has been a leading opponent.
"Many of the South Side's citizens see the NID tax as another opportunity for government waste and corruption," he said. "We pay for police protection, for public works, for code enforcement. Why should we pay more? Why should residents pay for a bar's profits?"
He said his extra tax would be about $1,200 annually.
"I clean my own sidewalk," he said. "There is already incentive for people to clean up in front of their buildings," especially if they have a business and want customers. "People are already stretched financially. Our assessments have gone up, we have a library tax, and we pay 3 percent wage tax."
Councilman Kraus, who attended the meeting and represents the South Side, said he will mail his decision to the forum in the next three weeks.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.