There probably aren't many public officials outside of Pike County, Pa., who have heard of the Mesivtah Eitz Chaim of Bobov Inc. summer camp.

But after a decision handed down last week by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court over whether the Brooklyn-based, Orthodox Jewish school's camp should be tax exempt, a lot of school, municipal and county officials will know about it now.

The court ruled that, although the camp is owned by a religious organization, most of the 61-acre spread is taxable because it did not meet all of the criteria previously established for charities in Pennsylvania and, as a result, it did not qualify as a purely public charity.

While some experts and parties involved in the case weren't sure if the ruling would mean a return to the 1980s and 1990s when the tax-exempt status of charities -- particularly hospitals -- was regularly challenged by local governments, others said the impact is obvious.

Advertise with us

"This is a game-changer," said Nicholas Cafardi, dean emeritus and professor at Duquesne University's Law School and an expert on charity law. "I have to think in these hard times when every municipality and school is stretched for resources, this opens the doors to challenges."

Drew Crompton, spokesman for state Senate President Pro Tem Joe Scarnati, said Senate leaders, who filed a bipartisan amicus brief in support of the Jewish camp last year, are so concerned that "at this point we're pondering whether we need to make clarification to the constitutional section on purely public charities."

It would take approval of a bill by the state House and Senate two years in a row, plus a statewide vote of the electorate, to change the state constitution.

The Supreme Court affirmed a Commonwealth Court ruling with a narrow 4-3 decision -- largely along party lines with three Republicans opposing the ruling, while three Democrats joined Republican Justice J. Michael Eakin, who wrote the majority opinion.

In the process, it overturned what many experts accepted as the legal standard for the past 15 years in determining what organizations qualified as purely public charities.

Advertise with us

Most importantly, the court ruled that the controlling point was not a 1997 state law known as Act 55 that was approved by the Legislature and signed by the governor. Instead, it was the court's own 1985 decision that established a five-prong test for charities in the case Hospital Utilization Project v. Commonwealth, a finding commonly known as the HUP test.

"We affirm, holding our prior jurisprudence sets the constitutional minimum for exemption from taxes; the legislation may codify what is intended to be exempted, but it cannot lessen the constitutional minimums by broadening the definition of 'purely public charity' in the statute," Justice Eakin wrote, in part.

The "prior jurisprudence" refers to the HUP test the court crafted in 1985 that said a purely public charity must pass each of five tests: advance a charitable purpose; donate or render gratuitously a substantial portion of its services; benefit a substantial and indefinite class of persons who are legitimate subjects of charity; operate entirely free from private profit motive; and relieve the government of some of its burden.

The court last week found that the Jewish camp met all but one of the five tests, that of relieving government of some of its burden. The camp argued that it relieved the government burden by "creating greater moral and social awareness in society."

Passage of Act 55, which set out a definition of what a purely public charity is, largely ended challenges to the tax-exempt status of charitable organizations across the state. It was the ruling of the HUP test -- which was considered by local governments to be a tougher challenge for charities to meet -- that launched 12 years of charitable challenges by schools, municipalities and counties.

Advertise with us

While supporters of Act 55 have always said that it provided "clarity" about what a purely public charity is, opponents, such as Mr. Cafardi and others, have long maintained that it simply "watered down" the definition so almost any organization could qualify -- something opponents say is demonstrated by the fact that charities have rarely been challenged since Act 55 was approved.

The Supreme Court's ruling, handed down April 25, has slowly found its ways into the hands of public officials and legal experts over the past week, generating a vigorous discussion of its impact.

"It's swinging it back to a tougher test. Act 55 swung the pendulum toward a more lenient test, and everybody who wanted exemptions was very happy about that and everybody who represents taxing authorities was unhappy about that," said M. Janet Burkardt, an attorney with the Law Offices of Ira Weiss, solicitor for Pittsburgh Public Schools. "Finally, the pendulum has swung back."

"I think it's an important decision," said Pittsburgh lawyer Raymond N. Baum, who has represented nonprofits since 1973. "For big institutions, if they wanted to go after, say, a UPMC, this would probably give them a little more to work with. But it's not surprising."

Ms. Burkardt said she believes the current decision makes it clear with "finality" which test takes precedence, citing a section of last week's ruling that says: "If you do not qualify under the HUP test, you never get to the statute."

Advertise with us

"I think it's a pro-taxpayer ruling," said Stuart L. Knade, chief counsel for the Pennsylvania School Boards Association, which filed a friend-of-the-court brief supporting the court's primacy.

Mr. Knade said the decision's implications are "huge," but not because he envisions a new flurry of litigation against tax-exempt entities. Rather, the decision allows the HUP-test standard to remain in place.

"People who are students of this area of the law are going to continue to enforce a higher bar to tax exemption ... than Act 55 would set. If people aren't looking at it as carefully, Act 55 may continue to be an easy door for people to slip through."

Paula Bussard, senior vice president for policy and regulatory services for the Hospital and Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania, which also filed a brief in the case, said: "We were disappointed" in the ruling.

But, she said: "Does this now mean there will be a lot of challenges? It's too early to tell."