It was a Friday night in February with the temperature hovering in the 40s.

TechMan fetched a beverage from the refrigerator. After sitting back down, he heard the dinging that indicated the refrigerator door was still open. He was sure he closed it, but went back and gave it a shove just in case.

After a minute, the dinging began again.

TechMan, with his laser-like focus, sensed right away that something was wrong. The other clue was that the temperature reading on the front of the refrigerator began to rise.

Advertise with us

And there was the incessant dinging. Ding. Ding. Ding. TechMan tried to ignore it. But it was like the beating of the telltale heart. The only way to stop it was to unplug the refrigerator.

So the contents of the refrigerator and freezer were moved into a small one in the basement, a cooler in the garage and a neighbor's freezer.

The next morning I called the appliance repairman. He was very nice and came that afternoon. He plugged in the refrigerator, which immediately began to run -- and to ding.

He punched a little white plastic plunger at the intersection of the freezer and refrigerator doors.

"There's the problem," he said. "The switch is bad."

Advertise with us

He said he'd have to replace it. Glancing at the brand name, he said, "Might not be easy to get parts."

Then came the Catch-22.

"The refrigerator and freezer will work fine. I'll remove the light bulb in the fridge and you can use it."

"Is there any way to disable the dinger?" I asked.

"Nope, it's built into the circuit board."

Advertise with us

I plugged it back in. Ding. Ding. Ding. Ding ad nauseam. No way. I unplugged it.

Because of the failure of a dinger switch and a bit of bad engineering, I was transported back into the time before domestic refrigeration.

As far as I can tell, the dinger switch has only two reasons to exist: to turn off the light inside the fridge and turn off the dinger when the door is closed.

At least I assume it turns off the light. That's not easy to prove.

But the dinger switch is a stress point. It has to perform every time the door is opened or closed. A quick check of the Internet told me a dinger switch sold for $11.75.

Advertise with us

I got to thinking: What would possess anyone to design a refrigerator with a dinger that could not be disabled?

Perhaps the engineer who designed it was some embittered Yoda who dreamed of designing rockets but ended up designing refrigerators.

I envisioned a small, stooped, wrinkled, warty engineer poring over his drawings muttering, "Put the dinger on the circuit board, will I."

Or maybe I was being punished for buying a foreign-made appliance, like when steelworkers yelled obscenities at me while driving my foreign car on the streets of Pittsburgh in the '70s.

I tried to look at the bright side. If I had bought one of those Internet-connected refrigerators, it could be tweeting over and over again: door open, door open, door open. Soon there would be a hashtag -- #annoyingrefrigerator.

Advertise with us

So it was back to the days of root cellars. If it had been a normal winter, I could have put the beer in the snowdrift outside the kitchen door.

The fridge actually got fixed in four days and I am back in the modern world with convenient refrigeration. Total cost of repair: $150.

It got me thinking. How many things are designed so that the failure of a small part like a switch makes the whole device unusable? How many devices have their switches and hinges and other vital parts made of cheap materials?

Probably the most famous switch failure was at the Three Mile Island nuclear power plant in 1979, when the pilot-operated relief valve stuck open, permitted coolant water to escape from the primary system.

How much do you think that valve cost in comparison to the cost of a nuclear reactor?

Advertise with us

Consumer goods grow more complicated, have more stress points and are under constant pressure to be less expensive. That means they contain cheap parts to do critical functions.

And guess who ends up getting dinged.