SAN FRANCISCO -- Google has sparked a controversy by changing its search results to add content from its fledgling Google+ social network. That includes posts, photos, profiles and conversations from Google+ that are public or were shared privately with the person searching.
With the new feature introduced Tuesday, which Google calls Search Plus Your World, the company is once again reimagining what people want from its search engine. It is betting that they are looking for more personalized and timely updates than it has been offering, as it competes with Facebook and others for users' time.
"What you search today is largely written by people you don't know; we call that the faceless Web," said Amit Singhal, a Google Fellow who oversees search. "Search Plus Your World transforms search and centers it around you."
But many people turn to Google for links to expert information and might not want their search results to be cluttered with friends' postings, or find it disconcerting to see personal information from friends in search results.
For some experts the new feature also raised antitrust concerns, because in many instances Google will show information from its social network before or instead of others.
Twitter said it was concerned that Google's change would make timely information from Twitter more difficult to find on Google.
"We think that's bad for people, publishers, news organizations and Twitter users," the company said in a statement.
Danny Sullivan, an expert on the search industry and editor of the blog Search Engine Land, said Google was right that people wanted to see social posts -- but most of those posts are on other social networks.
"A lot of it is not on Google+," he said. "Google's job should be, what are the best social accounts I should be following, not the best Google+ accounts I should be following."
Google said its search engine already showed some material from sites such as Flickr and Twitter when users link their accounts to their Google profile, and that it would include material from sites such as Facebook if the companies would make it available.
Facebook, which does not allow Google to include most of its pages in search results, declined to comment.
Under the new system, Google users can click a link on a page of search results to see only personal posts, or turn off the new feature and see only standard search results. Users who have not signed up for Google+ will see any other items they have shared with Google, like photos they have uploaded to its Picasa service and items posted publicly on Google+ by people Google assumes they know because they communicate with them on Gmail, for instance.
The changes show how important Google+ is to the company. By failing to get on board with social networking sooner, Google risked being left behind. Search Plus Your World comes eight years after Facebook started and in the weeks before Facebook is expected to file for an initial public offering.
To keep up, Larry Page, Google's chief executive, prioritized social features and introduced Google+ last summer.
Google has said it does not want to replace Facebook. Rather, the company wants to have a service that supplies it with social information that it can use in its other products, such as Gmail.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.