Those wily Congress members are at it again, trying to play fast and loose with the Internet at the behest of their moneyed buddies in the music and film businesses.

The last attempt to stop piracy of movies and music was called the Combating Online Infringement and Counterfeits Act (COICA). It never came to a vote; however, two zombie bills have now arisen from the corpse, one in the House and one in the Senate, that are even more draconian.

The Senate bill is called the PROTECT IP Act (PIPA), which takes its tortured acronym from Preventing Real Online Threats to Economic Creativity and Theft of Intellectual Property. It has cleared the Senate Judiciary Committee, but has not yet been put to a vote.

The Senate version would allow the U.S. Department of Justice to seek court orders requiring search engines and Internet providers to stop sending traffic to websites accused of infringing copyrights. The bill also would allow copyright holders to seek court orders requiring payment processors and online ad networks to stop doing business with allegedly infringing websites.

Advertise with us

But the most radical part of the bill would allow the imposition of a "death sentence" on sites deemed to be violating copyright.

The court could require an offending site's numerical address to be removed from the Domain Names System, effectively making the targeted website invisible on the Internet in the United States.

The act would allow copyright owners -- movie studios and other content providers -- simply to accuse a website of infringement to get such court orders.

On Wednesday a similar bill was introduced into the House of Representatives that has many of the features of the Senate bill and goes even further.

Demand Progress, a civil liberties group opposed to the legislation, says the House version would overturn parts of the 13-year-old Digital Millennium Copyright Act that protect websites and Internet providers from copyright lawsuits for the infringing activity of their users.

Advertise with us

"Our allies on [Capitol] Hill say the bill's so bad that it could effectively destroy YouTube, Twitter and other sites that rely on user-generated content by making the sites' owners legally responsible for everything their users post," the group said.

According to the Los Angeles Times, film studios, TV networks and entertainment industry labor groups have launched an education campaign to teach the public about the evils of piracy and prod their employees and union members to support an anti-piracy bill.

In a letter to the Senate, supporters of the bill said: "Internet sites that steal and distribute American intellectual property are often foreign-owned and operated, or reside at domain names that are not registered through a U.S.-based registry or registrar, setting them outside the effective scope of U.S. law enforcement jurisdiction."

Opposing the bills are electronics trade groups, law professors and Internet entrepreneurs.

A group of law professors says the bills' most visible flaw is the unconstitutional restriction of speech. The group said the Supreme Court had rejected prior restraint, which is exactly what the bill would allow were it to go into effect -- a judge would be able to shut down websites upon an application by the attorney general without notice and a proper hearing to the adverse party.

Advertise with us

Gary Shapiro, head of the Consumer Electronics Association that represents makers of entertainment and other devices, wrote for Forbes Magazine about the Senate version: "The bill is so broadly written that, in theory, it would allow any copyright owner to shut down a legitimate retail website, such as Amazon or Best Buy, by alleging that one product being sold on the site could "enable or facilitate" an infringement.

So what does TechMan think of these bills?

He thinks it is burning down the house to roast the pig.

Let your legislators know what you think.