A front-page story in the Post-Gazette this week reported on a "powerful new tool" being tested by police in Washington County -- a police cruiser-mounted camera system that can scan license plates and report them back to a database.
While I, of course, support law enforcement using high-tech tools, these types of systems seem to take us one step closer to a surveilled society, where information about innocent people is hoovered up, stored and indexed during the search for drug dealers and terrorists.
The ACLU says its concern in this case was not so much that the information is collected, but whether it is stored in law enforcement databases. State police use a similar system, but it does not save the data about nonsuspect vehicles.
Indeed, one of the decisions the Washington County district attorney says he has to make is whether the information is stored or purged. Keep an eye on that decision.
The Washington County system, manufactured by Federal Signal Corp., costs $100,000 to outfit six police departments patrolling Route 19 and is being paid for mostly with federal funds.
But in addition to privacy concerns, TechMan is curious about how such technology, known as ALPR (automatic license plate recognition) or AVI (automatic vehicle identification), works. (What follows is a general description, not specific to the Washington County system.)
First let's look at the camera. Far from being a simple snapshot-taker, the camera has to compensate for challenges in getting a clear picture of a license plate on a moving vehicle. It also has infrared capability so it can work at night. The specialized camera usually hooks up to a computer in the trunk of the cruiser that increases image readability.
When a reading of the license plate is obtained, it is reported to a computer database and compared with plates of stolen cars or of cars with owners who have warrants out on them.
If a match is made it is reported back to the officer on the in-car laptop computer.
It is because these cameras operate constantly and record all the license plates in the area of a cruiser that privacy advocates are worried.
In addition to license plate numbers, these systems can record dates, time, speed of the vehicle and GPS coordinates.
Obviously there are opportunities for abuse. One of the most egregious examples was in 2004 and involved an Edmonton Sun reporter in Canada. After he wrote an article critical of police use of traffic cameras for creating revenue, he was added to a database of high-risk drivers so his driving habits could be monitored and maybe provide an opportunity to arrest him.
The police chief and several officers were fired as a result.
So is the point to make you more nervous than ever about a police cruiser following behind your car on Route 19?
No. It is only to have you realize, as TechMan has said many times before, that we live in a changing world brought about by video, database search and character and face recognition technology.
Assume that there is nowhere in public (and in your home while surfing the Internet) that you have complete privacy.
The chance is that someone is tracking you or storing the GPS coordinates of your cell phone or comparing your face or your license number or your E-ZPass sticker to entries in a database.
As a state police lieutenant was quoted as saying in the PG article, "When your vehicle is on a public road, you don't have an expectation of privacy,"
That's just the way it is, and it looks like it's going to be even more so in the future.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.