Many books are written about how successful entrepreneurs took their ideas from concept to market, but I have not run across one that talks about how universities turn the intellectual property of their professors and students into fully operating businesses. So I sat down with Reed McManigle, manager of business development and licensing at Carnegie Mellon University's Center for Technology Transfer and Enterprise Creation.

He's one of those responsible for turning product ideas from around the campus into licensable products or even businesses, a process known in the industry as technology transfer.

A few surprises came out of the discussion: first, that tech transfer at CMU takes a number of paths, not just running through a fixed process; second, that the university doesn't lay claim to all the technology that comes out of campus; and third, that one of the more challenging parts of the process is to find out who has technology that might be available to turn into money-making products or services.

That third point means Mr. McManigle and others in the department often need to seek out professors and students whose research might be commercializable.

Advertise with us

Those students and professors don't always come forward looking for help. Perhaps that's because in many university environments, the university wants to keep part ownership. According to Mr. McManigle, though, at Carnegie Mellon, they want only a piece if it was funded by the university or grants related to the university.

That doesn't mean that the Center for Technology Transfer and Enterprise Creation doesn't want to help monetize other ideas from professors and students, nor that they won't take a fee to do it. The center attempts to provide a nurturing environment for those ideas too, occasionally even helping get additional funding to commercialize the ideas. So the center is often trying to get professors to think about commercialization -- very different from the tradition of being focused on publishing research.

The first step after recognizing an idea is to determine who actually owns it, based on who paid for the development to-date and other factors. Then paperwork is put in place, and CMU works with the University of Pittsburgh Law School to determine whether the product or idea is patentable and, if so, helps start the patent process to protect the intellectual property.

They also need to work with the inventor and others -- MBAs, alumni and other valued helpers -- to determine whether the concept represents a licensing opportunity or should be turned into a startup company.

In either case, the university signs an agreement with the inventor designating who pays for what, who is responsible for what activities and how the ownership or revenue structure will go forward. At CMU, it's not a negotiation of fees or schedules; those are preset depending on what is needed from the university -- it's more of a determination of who is best suited based on resources, know-how and desire.

Advertise with us

Carnegie Mellon has been successful since the early '90s in helping commercialize ideas from campus. Some ideas were quite lucrative, such as Lycos. (CMU built Newell-Simon Hall from the profits it received from Lycos' initial public offering.) Other successes include ReCapcha, which was sold to Google in less than two years, and Carnegie Learning.

The center's staff of eight people has helped spin off an average of 10 companies a year for the past six years; and the center has 20 to 30 potential startups in the queue at any given time. CMU ranks second in the country in number of startups per research dollar spent (behind the University of Utah).