Beating the New York Times digital subscription policy, or paywall, has become something of a sport on the Internet even before the paper's plan to charge for digital content has launched.

The Times announced in January 2010 that it would begin to charge for unlimited access to its content on its website, smartphone applications and tablet computer apps.

Digital subscriptions begin Monday. The Times is already testing the system in Canada.

The paywall is an attempt to solve a problem that has been bedeviling the newspaper industry for more than a decade and causing newspaper closings and bankruptcies across the country. As the money newspapers make from print ads and subscriptions drops, revenue from online advertising has not grown fast enough to make up for the losses.

Advertise with us

Charging for access to content online is a way to help close the digital/print revenue gap.

But charging for access is a two-edged sword. Many digital readers will stop visiting a website that was free and now has a fee. That loss in "eyeballs" threatens the money that is being made from online advertisements.

The Times has tried to avert that problem with a paywall that allows some free access, but charges for full access to its content. The system is designed with numerous ways to see content for free.

"We don't want to drive people away from the site." said Times spokeswoman Eileen Murphy. "We want to maintain our place in the digital ecosystem."

It is these "free passes" that have allowed the games to begin on the Internet to bypass the digital subscription charge.

Advertise with us

Under the Times plan, any user can see up to 20 digital articles a month free. Article 21 and thereafter for the remainder of the month are obscured by a gray semitransparent box that tells the user how to subscribe.

There are exceptions. Articles on the homepage of the website and fronts of sections don't count against the monthly 20. The Top News sections on smartphones and tablets apps also don't count.

Bloomberg has reported that it cost between $40 million and $50 million to implement the paywall.

The gaping hole in the paywall is that any Times article accessed by a link from another website or a search engine also does not count.

That means a link to a Times story on Twitter or Facebook or Google or Bing or a blog, allows free access ... with limits.

Advertise with us

Martin A. Nisenholtz, senior vice president, digital operations for The New York Times, realizes the significance of this and said the Times will monitor such access. But he says Times research shows many people will be willing to pay.

"I think the majority of people are honest and care about great journalism and the New York Times. ... At the same time we want to make sure that we're not being gamed, to the extent that we can be."

The pricing structure also is somewhat unconventional. If you subscribe to the print paper, you get full digital access for free, including through the smartphone and tablet apps.

For nonsubscribers, full digital access costs $15 per four weeks for desktop/laptop plus smartphone app; $20 for desktop/laptop plus tablet; and $35 for all digital access. Full digital access with a home-delivered print subscription is $32 or less depending on discounts.

The Times already has started to close some of the holes in the paywall.

Advertise with us

Ms. Murphy said the Times has reached agreement with "a majority of the search engines" to limit links to Times content to five a day. However links from other sites remain unlimited.

Recently the Times asked Twitter to shut down @freenyt, an account that tweeted links to all Times articles so they could be read for free.

Ms. Murphy said that wasn't done to protect the paywall, but was a matter of violation of trademark.

"That's nothing new," she said.

But the very structure of the paywall is leaky, too. A Canadian coder has posted a free program on the Web that he says contains just four lines of code he cooked up during lunch.

Advertise with us

He claims that if you put a link to the program in your browser, clicking it will remove the obscuring box asking you to pay, allowing you to read the article for free.

Ms. Murphy said the Times would likely look for "serious abuse. But that is not our focus right now."

Meanwhile, it is a safe bet that other schemes to breach the paywall will show up.

But the Times and other papers that are considering charging for digital content (the Post-Gazette does not charge for content on post-gazette.com) hope readers realize that there is value in newspaper journalism that is worth paying for.

Times editor Bill Keller, in a memo to the newsroom announcing the release of four Times journalists held in Libya said, "In a week when we have dared to declare that the work we do is worth paying for, this is a reminder that real, boots-on-the-ground journalism is hard and sometimes dangerous work."