When friends came to visit Shirley Hernandez in her new house in Penn Hills in 2007, they raved about it.
"Oh my God, Shirl, this is so nice," she recalls them saying.
Then she discovered mold growing throughout the basement. The downstairs bathroom stopped working, windows froze over and the furnace broke.
Worried her two kids would get sick from the mold, she left the home. "They said, 'Why, mommy, are we moving out of our house?' " she said.
Ms. Hernandez became part of a downward spiral of foreclosure sales that is increasingly common in some neighborhoods.
A lender had taken the deed to the property and sold it to a local investor for $36,100, who then flipped it to Ms. Hernandez, nearly doubling his money in two months. But saddled with a defective home and a mortgage she couldn't afford, Ms. Hernandez let the home go back into foreclosure, where an Ohio-based investor bought it for $3,122. In just three years, the house lost, apparently, 90 percent of its value.
That kind of cycle has multiple effects on neighborhoods, said Robert M. Gradeck, a research project manager at the University Center for Social and Urban Research at the University of Pittsburgh, who has studied foreclosures. Properties flow to investors, who may or may not maintain them. Values trend downward, making it hard for homeowners to borrow against their houses or sell them. "People who might want to be an owner in a place like that might be discouraged," by vacancies, he said.
Foreclosed homes in the 1990s made up just one in 25 Allegheny County residential property sales, according to RealSTATs, a local real estate information service. Since 2006, though, one in seven county residential sales has come through the foreclosure process, making homes taken by lenders an important part of the housing market.
Foreclosed properties are "fertile ground for fraud in a lot of different ways," said Assistant U.S. Attorney Brendan T. Conway, who prosecutes mortgage fraud.
"One of the keys to any mortgage fraud is creating a gap between what you buy a property for and what you're ultimately going to sell the property for," he said. Since foreclosed properties are available at low prices, there can be a temptation to inflate the values using deceptive appraisals, entice buyers with promises of repairs, and arrange mortgages using fake documentation of buyers' assets and down payments.
His office last month indicted Dov Ratchkauskas of Squirrel Hill and George Kubini of Shadyside, accusing them of selling post-foreclosure properties to buyers -- including Ms. Hernandez -- for whom they arranged mortgages backed by lies.
The foreclosure market's unique characteristics stem from the fact that banks take the properties of borrowers who don't make payments but have no reason to hold onto them.
"Banks have decided that liquidation as a model looks better than repossessing houses and holding the asset for the long haul," said Michael Sichenzia, a mortgage expert based in South Florida, which has faced an epidemic of foreclosures. "You will start to see a rise in the number of sales, yet increasing downward pressure on prices."
Banks initially seek to recoup what they lost on the loan through the sale of the foreclosed property, said Dan Murrer, vice president of RealSTATs. The discounts, though, come quickly.
"As a property sits, the carrying costs to the bank increase -- taxes, insurance, maintenance, utilities, etc. -- and the risk of vandalism and copper/aluminum theft increases," he said. Down goes the asking price.
In Pittsburgh in 2009, homes that had been through recent foreclosures typically sold for around one-quarter of the price of those that hadn't been affected by a foreclosure filing, according to research by Mr. Gradeck, who manages the Pittsburgh Neighborhood and Community Information System.
The post-foreclosure property segment is tough to tap for community groups and conventional developers, which might otherwise be able to steer the homes to responsible homeowners.
"We have heard that large investors have information sources so they're able to buy properties before they're even listed," said Mary Helen Petrus, a community affairs manager at the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, which includes Pittsburgh in its territory. The Cleveland Fed has studied post-foreclosure properties, and found that investors who buy them in bulk tend to ignore their property taxes, which has the effect of allowing them to outbid more responsible buyers who factor taxes into their decisions.
Kendall Pelling, a project manager for East Liberty Development Inc., kept seeing foreclosed properties fall into the hands of "slumlords and other low-quality property investors," he said. His nonprofit employer had him get a real estate license so he could tap listings that aren't available to the general public or typical neighborhood do-gooders.
That helped. "We bought a whole bunch of foreclosures over the course of the last few years," he said. "But it's still a tricky process.
"The banks have an interest in liquidating the property quickly, without contingencies or other factors in the agreement," he said. "They want somebody with cash, with no inspections, with no representations or warranties."
A coalition of national nonprofit groups, working with around 20 lenders, has created a program, called First Look, that gives community organizations five days to look at a foreclosed property before it goes on the market to investors. It has placed 3,200 properties with neighborhood groups so far, but none in Pittsburgh. ELDI became the first local organization to sign up for First Look last month.
Can tools like First Look keep homes out of a cycle of foreclosures? "When we have the cash available, which isn't always, and when we're able to catch the properties at the right time, which isn't always," said Mr. Pelling, "when everything works right, yes."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.