They had to turn up the lights recently at Joseph-Beth Booksellers and Aspinwall Bookshop. But it was not so it would be easier to read. The bright lights made it easier for South Side ad agency FiremanCreative to film a commercial that you won't see on TV, but on the computer.
Online video is consuming an ever larger piece of Americans' viewing time, up to three hours on average for 75 percent of Internet users in July, according to digital research firm comScore Inc.
Anything that popular is sure to attract the attention of ad agencies, which are carving a niche somewhere between the grainy, homemade videos that helped establish YouTube.com in the first place and the high-production, big-budget television ads seen during prime-time shows.
It likely will take a few years for online video to start controlling a significant piece of the nation's advertising budget. For every $100 U.S. marketers spend on TV commercials this year, they'll spend just $1.10 for video ads on the Web, according to a report by David Hallerman, senior analyst for online consulting firm eMarketer.
By 2011, the eMarketer analyst is projecting advertisers could spend four times as much on online video advertising.
The industry uses the term to include ads made to be posted on video sharing sites and Web sites targeting specific audiences, in addition to short videos that might run right before a user watches a news video or a movie clip. A number of sites are experimenting with how to add video ads without turning off viewers.
As in the early years of television in the 1950s, the first online video offerings tended to be kind of rough, noted Jason Bergeron, creative director at agency Ten United's Downtown office. The technology was embraced by individuals who could play with the medium and post the results for a wider audience. Some advertisers showed what could be done commercially with pieces of the Dove videos that challenged the images of beauty often presented in advertising, but there also has been an abundance of material online that was created for TV and just "repurposed" for the Web.
Demand seems to be growing for commercial work done specifically for online. Making such material requires a different technique, according to ad agency executives, but it could open up opportunities.
For one thing, the price of cameras and editing equipment that has dropped enough to allow garage filmmakers to free their inner muse also can drop the price tag on agency work. And as anyone who has posted a personal karaoke performance on YouTube or MySpace knows, Internet space doesn't run up bills the way 30 seconds during "Grey's Anatomy" would.
"Even on a smaller budget, you can do it," said Mr. Bergeron, who cited the example of a potential client in the auto parts business that is now discussing the possibilities of advertising online.
Paul Fireman began working with publisher HarperCollins more than a year ago after he read a newspaper article that discussed the company's interest in doing movie-style trailers for books. Now he estimates 20 percent of his small agency's work involves online video.
That includes Walnut Capital's mixed-use real estate project, Bakery Square in East Liberty, which uses online video to make the development come alive for potential tenants, and Oakmont manufacturer Sima Products Corp., which is trying the technique to raise awareness of consumer electronics products.
Agencies believe that they can sell clients the storytelling skills and marketing strategy honed over the years through more traditional media. Of course, that's going to cost more than a do-it-yourself project but they expect that the work also is more effective.
The sheer newness of the medium gives agencies the chance to break out from the television norms.
"Even the most creative of television did have a tendency to become a formula to some extent," said Mr. Bergeron.
Yet professional marketers must tread carefully in the new theater. On the Web, a slick advertisement might do more harm than good.
"There's a whole new visual language that consumers and people in the online world grew up with," said Brian Bronaugh, president and executive creative director at Strip District agency Mullen.
Mr. Bergeron had a similar take. "I think where you can go wrong is where you make it too salesy." Ten United worked on a campaign for Columbus, Ohio, pizza maker Donatos that featured a pizza-folding theme called pizzagami. Some of the spots were done for TV, but some aired only online.
Often the tone online needs to have more attitude.
FiremanCreative's promotional video for the new book, "A Lifetime of Secrets," by "PostSecret" author Frank Warren takes a rather inspirational and even moody tone. There are voices of people sharing their secrets, which range from sexy to sweet. The video, which lasts 2 minutes and 41 seconds, has been viewed almost half a million times on YouTube in the past month.
Besides the creative differences, the agency's team has learned to adapt to the technical challenges of making an online ad -- everything from the different screen size to making sure everything works well with different Web browsers, from Internet Explorer to Mozilla and Safari. "I think we've learned a lot because we're doing it a lot more," said Mr. Fireman.
Another drawback to doing online video has been the chaotic environment on the Web. Advertisers wonder, he said, "How effectively can you do this in this medium where you have bikini-clad, dancing women and lots of smug bloggers?"
Putting videos on a company's own site or on a community site that draws the right crowd makes it harder to get lost in what can be "a sea of garbage," Mr. Fireman added. "PostSecret" fans who follow Mr. Warren's blog know where to find the videos. They, in turn, send links to their friends.
Online video's strength is reaching these kinds of specific audiences. Even then, the video has to earn its airtime. Viewers may not be picky about the production values, but the work must be creative or relevant enough that people seek it out.
That's another difference between TV and online video: "There's still nothing that can spread mass awareness like television," noted Mr. Bergeron.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.