Here's an ugly, but obvious, guiding truth about politics: The more money you give to someone, the harder it is for them to say no to you. That's why a lot of politicians, from Pittsburgh to Philadelphia to Washington, D.C., will have to think twice before saying no to Highmark.

Why does that matter? Because Pittsburgh-based Highmark Inc. wants to join with Philadelphia's Independence Blue Cross, creating one of the largest health insurers in the country and giving rise to antitrust concerns among patient groups and industry rivals.

Highmark Health PAC campaign finance reports

State: Details of Highmark Health PAC contributions from 2006 are available in reports posted on the Pennsylvania Department of State's Campaign Finance Reporting Web site.

Advertise with us

Cycle 1, 6th Tuesday Pre-Primary

Cycle 2, 2nd Friday Pre-Primary

Cycle 3, 30-Day Post-Primary

Cycle 4, 6th Tuesday Pre-Election

Cycle 5, 2nd Friday Pre-Election

Advertise with us

Cycle 6, 30-Day Post-Election

Cycle 7, Annual Report

Federal: Details of Highmark Health PAC contributions are available in reports posted on the Federal Election Commission's Campaign Finance Reports and Data Web site.

2005-2006 contributions to federal candidates

An index to Highmark Health PAC's quarterly reports

Advertise with us

The proposed merger, unveiled last month, "definitely is going to be the priority until we get that accomplished," said Mike Warfel, Highmark's lobbyist-in-chief and vice president of government affairs.

Highmark and Independence will need at least tacit approval from the state Legislature, and the more explicit kind from Republican Attorney General Tom Corbett, Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell and his insurance commissioner. On a federal level, it might need senators, congressmen or even the president to call off the Justice Department dogs.

Highmark has covered all the bases, providing campaign contributions to the governor, the attorney general, congressmen, President Bush and both Pennsylvania senators over the years.

From its creation in 1996 with the merger of Blue Cross of Western Pennsylvania and Pennsylvania Blue Shield, Highmark has been building its political clout. Among the 30 or so Blue Cross Blue Shield health insurers still operating in the United States, Highmark is in the top five when it comes to political activity. According to Federal Election Commission documents, only Blues plans based in Florida and Michigan, as well as the massive, multistate WellPoint company, have contributed more federal money since the 1990s.

"Everybody knows Highmark," said Rep. John Maher, R-Upper St. Clair, himself a recipient of Highmark money during his 2006 campaign.

Advertise with us

"Forgetting their own merger thing, there's always issues in the insurance industry," from tort reform to Medicaid reimbursement levels to the governor's "Prescription for Pennsylvania," a plan to expand health-care coverage and improve its quality

On a national level, the Blues are interested in the health-care proposals put out by the 2008 presidential candidates, and also hope to fend off any changes to the McCarran-Ferguson Act, which has given the insurance industry immunity from federal antitrust laws.

Speaking of national politics, Highmark last week agreed to pay a fine of more than $54,000 after noticing that it had used corporate money, instead of political committee cash, on fund-raisers connected to former Sen. Rick Santorum.

The penalty may have been a bit of a surprise, but less so was that Mr. Santorum was the beneficiary. When it comes to federal contributions, according to the Federal Election Commission, Highmark leans heavily Republican, committing nine out of every 10 dollars to GOP candidates or related fund-raising committees.

Mr. Santorum's America's Foundation was a top recipient last year, receiving at least $5,000 in direct contributions from the Highmark Health Political Action Committee (PAC). That doesn't include the thousands more that Highmark helps to raise through fund-raisers. Mr. Santorum, in the 2005-2006 campaign cycle, was the single biggest recipient on insurance industry donations, collecting in excess $477,000.

Advertise with us

On a state level, Highmark's contributions to Republicans still outweigh those to Democrats, but the gap is less drastic.

In 2006, for example, Highmark's biggest contributions went to Gov. Rendell, who was running for reelection against GOP challenger Lynn Swann. Mr. Rendell also received private contributions from high-ranking Highmark employees, including Chief Executive Officer Ken Melani, who gave at least $30,000 to Mr. Rendell, state records show. Scott Becker, a company vice president, gave at least $4,000 to the governor.

On the Republican side, major beneficiaries included party leaders such as former House Speaker John Perzel, former Senate Republican Leader David Brightbill, former Sen. Robert Jubelirer and House Leader Sam Smith, of Punxsutawney.

Local politicians such as state Sen. Jane Orie, Auditor General Jack Wagner and Allegheny County Chief Executive Dan Onorato also were among the hundreds of recipients of Highmark money, with Mr. Onorato receiving an $8,000 check late last year.

In all, according to paperwork filed with the Department of State, Highmark's PAC disbursed more than $163,000 in 2006.

Advertise with us

A bit of that money is spent on its own expenses, and some of it goes to other political committees, business groups such as the Greater Pittsburgh Chamber of Commerce or the Blue Cross Blue Shield umbrella PAC. But most goes directly to politicians and their campaign coffers. The money doesn't come from the corporate side or from the Blues' much publicized surplus, but from employee contributions.

The company also spends hundreds of thousands on lobbying.

Unlike some company PACs of similar size, which support a few select candidates with giant checks, Highmark spreads its money more thinly. It targets leadership positions first, then moves to committee heads, then, finally, to rank-and-file types, who can expect a check for less than $1,000 in an election year.

"We make a wide array of contributions," lobbyist Warfel said, explaining the PAC's strategy.

Philadelphia consumer watchdog Jon Stein said Highmark has so effectively sewn its political contributions through the various branches of state government that you'd have a difficult time finding someone who hasn't received money from Highmark over the last four years. As a result, "they don't want to rock the boat," Mr. Stein said, meaning the politicians, not Highmark.

Advertise with us

He thinks a bill now being considered by the state Legislature, which would give the Insurance Department authority over the proposed merger -- something it doesn't have right now, thanks to a unique gap in Pennsylvania law -- is without bite.

State Rep. Mark Cohen, a Philadelphia Democrat, says the law needs additional provisions -- perhaps language that creates an insurance watchdog provision, similar to the state's consumer advocate, who monitors utilities. Or the law could include language that says Highmark and Independence must demonstrate some degree of "public benefit" before the merger is approved.

But Mr. Cohen doesn't think that will happen. "I think the governor would like quick action," he said.

In boxing terms, Highmark might be considered a light heavyweight. The $163,000 it spent in 2006 -- $151,000 in 2005, $147,000 in 2004, $126,000 in 2003 and $145,000 in 2002, according to State Department receipts -- puts the insurer in a category with big names such as Verizon's Pennsylvania PAC (which spent $157,000 in 2006), the AFL-CIO of Pennsylvania ($103,629), and the Pennsylvania Medical Society ($206,000), a doctors lobbying group.

But it comes up short of the true heavyweights. In 2006, the Pennsylvania State Education Association's political arm, called PACE, gave $510,000 -- and that was just to Mr. Rendell. In all, it told the Pennsylvania State Department that it had spent $1.7 million.

Advertise with us

Still, it's the biggest Blue contributor in-state. Highmark, by itself, bests the contributions made by Pennsylvania's overall Blue Cross Blue Shield committee, known as BluePAC, which draws money from Independence as well as Highmark's Harrisburg-based rival, Capital BlueCross. In total, the BluePAC reported $131,000 in spending last year, with about $24,000 coming from Capital and the rest spent by Independence.

On a federal level, Independence, the insurer Highmark hopes to join, has given about half of what Highmark has since the 1990s. The split between Republican and Democratic candidates and causes is about 60-40, in favor of the GOP, for Independence.

Mr. Warfel said Highmark's pronounced split is not necessarily rooted in ideology. It just happens that Pennsylvania has had two Republican senators, a Republican governor and a GOP-controlled Legislature for much of the last dozen years. And it's smart to donate to leaders. "There's no magic to it," he said.

So far in 2007, Highmark has reported contributing nearly $50,000. Top recipients include the Senate Republican Campaign Committee ($3,000), GOP Congressman Tim Murphy ($3,000), and Lancaster Republican Sen. Gibson Armstrong ($1,000). Also making the 2007 list, covering contributions from Jan. 1 to the last week of March, were Sen. Don White, R-Indiana, and Rep. Todd Eachus, D-Luzerne, the two legislators responsible for sponsoring the bills that would give the insurance commissioner supervisory authority over the planned merger.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.