With liquids and gels now banned from carry-on luggage, flight attendant Bill Pratt came to a startling realization as he worked a US Airways flight between Pittsburgh and Philadelphia last week: Suddenly, there were no bags being checked at the gate.
Bob Donaldson, Post-Gazette
A passenger removes his shoes at the security checkpoint at Pittsburgh International Airport.
Click photo for larger image.
Related article
Family's Heathrow adventure: Lines, frisks, clear plastic bags
"I was amazed," said Mr. Pratt, who has worked with US Airways for 23 years and is used to seeing so many passengers try to carry on bags that the cabin runs out of storage room, forcing the bags to be checked. "There has been a change in how much people are trying to bring on the aircraft."
Joe Terrell, federal security director at Pittsburgh International Airport, said the increase in checked luggage has prompted some fine-tuning with staff scheduling.
"We've been going full-bore here," he said, "because we've had to change to accommodate the shift in passenger behavior.
"We wanted people to come earlier. They've done that. We wanted them to check bags. They've done that. We've checked 25 percent more bags than normal, and that means we have to put resources over there now."
The short-term shift in bags from the cabins to the bellies of planes could lead to difficult challenges for airlines and passengers if the temporary restrictions become permanent.
From an increased risk of lost bags to more people waiting for checked luggage, the new travel reality threatens to alienate airlines from the business travelers who are their bread and butter. What's more, carry-on restrictions that are creating a more orderly boarding process in the cabin could boost operating costs on the runway.
"There's nothing that holds up a plane more certainly than baggage handlers being unable to get the [cargo] hold loaded up, and a flight closed out," said Bill Lauer, a local airline analyst. "You add another little baggage train or two to everything and that will more than offset whatever time is saved by boarding passengers not having to fumble around with luggage going into the overheads."
Between 5 a.m. and 10 p.m. last Sunday, baggage belts at Pittsburgh International Airport that serve US Airways -- the carrier with the most flights out of here -- handled nearly 10,000 bags, a 30 percent jump compared with the previous Sunday, said JoAnn Jenny, spokeswoman for the Allegheny County Airport Authority.
The baggage handling system serving other carriers at Pittsburgh International has experienced a similar increase since the new federal regulations were imposed Thursday, Ms. Jenny said.
That's enough of a baggage bump to put pressure on airlines that are trying to handle bags quickly so that arriving flights can return to the air, said Mr. Lauer. As a result, airlines likely will spend more money on baggage handlers -- operating costs that probably will be passed on to passengers, he said.
As long as airlines increase staff accordingly, the increase in checked bags shouldn't result in longer waits at the baggage carousel, Mr. Lauer said. But lost luggage operates on a law of averages -- the more bags checked, the more that are likely to be mishandled.
"There is definitely a risk of more lost baggage, because as more and more travelers feel that they need to check a bag, the systems around the country are already at a peak and overloaded," said Kevin Mitchell of the Business Travel Coalition, an advocacy group for corporate travel managers. "So this could be a tipping point for a lot of these baggage systems to fail."
Airline officials say workers have put in the additional hours necessary to handle the increase in checked luggage and that security-related delays and lost bags have been minimal.
Ms. Jenny said Pittsburgh International's baggage handling system should be far from the tipping point because it was designed to handle the much larger volume of bags that came through the airport when it was a US Airways hub.
At Southwest Airlines, which has a reputation for quickly "turning" its airplanes, the increase in checked bags hasn't added to the amount of time planes spend at the gate so far, said Whitney Eichinger, a company spokeswoman.
Meanwhile, travelers have enjoyed differences in the cabin like those noted by US Airways spokeswoman Valerie Wunder, who flew over the weekend.
"When you check a bag, you're not fighting for overhead space, and you're not dodging rollerboards in the aisle," she said. "You're able to get on and off a lot more quickly."
But not everyone is happy.
"It's a huge pain," said Karen Kronauge, 33, of Denver, who travels four times a week on business for a software company. Yesterday, she flew into Pittsburgh, a trip she said she makes every month or so.
As an experienced business traveler, she had developed a streamlined routine that relied on carry-on luggage rather than checked baggage.
"I'm having to wait for luggage that I would never check. Ever. But it has hair spray in it," she said while waiting for her bag at one of the airport luggage carousels. "And I don't know any women who don't take their hair spray with them.
"I had to arrive at the airport much earlier to check my bag, so that added on a half-hour to 45 minutes at the beginning. And this is going to add 20 to 30 minutes waiting for my bag to come out."
Not only is it time-consuming, she said, but it wreaks havoc on her luggage.
"We all know they lose bags and damage bags. It often comes out different from the way they checked it.
"I don't know what can be done," she said. "Quite honestly, I think it's all for show."
Julie Trosdahl, 26, of Madison, Wis., came to Pittsburgh yesterday morning on business and was heading home yesterday afternoon.
"The inconvenience was I never would have checked luggage in the first place," she said. "But I had to, and then they lost it. So I had to buy some new stuff -- toothpaste, makeup, eye drops and stuff."
The result was that the things she owned were missing and the items that she bought to replace them had to be tossed -- barely used -- into a security trash bin.
"You just deal with it," she said, shrugging. "You can't dwell on the small things."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.