A proxy fight may be the closest thing the business pages have to a boxing match, complete with plenty of trash talking. Or maybe a reality TV show with voting by the audience.

So far, the one under way for five board seats at Pittsburgh's H.J. Heinz Co. has drawn charges of hypocrisy and countercharges of smear campaigns. The barbs being traded push such hot button issues as administrative costs, marketing strategy and corporate governance -- the kind of things that could get an executive spontaneously head-butted in the chest.

Despite countless filings by both parties dutifully submitted to the financial industry referee, the Securities and Exchange Commission, shareholders still may be puzzled.

"Does anyone really know that [Nelson] Peltz is going to do better than Heinz?" asked a poster on a Yahoo! message board in mid-July. "I really don't know how to vote."

Advertise with us

That message drew plenty of responses from people confident of their positions one way or the other, but even professional observers differ in their views. Here are some of the things that the two sides want shareholders to consider -- and not consider -- as they vote.

 ISSUE 1: Board Nominees

HEINZ

The company has assembled a board on which 11 of 12 directors are outsiders, although a few are Pittsburgh-based businessmen. The only Heinz employee on the board is William Johnson, who carries the titles of chairman, chief executive officer and president. Still, Heinz in July announced it would consider adding two more independent directors to the board at the suggestion of institutional investors. The search process for candidates is under way.

TRIAN

Advertise with us

The investor group's close-knit slate of five nominees includes two longtime business partners, Nelson Peltz and Peter W. May; Mr. Peltz's son-in-law and investment professional Edward Garden; Michael Weinstein, the former president of A&W Brands and former CEO of Snapple Beverage Group, where he worked for Mr. Peltz and Mr. May and led a rapid turnaround of that business; and golfer Greg Norman, who is a friend of Mr. Peltz but also a businessman with his own multinational corporation.

DISPUTED TERRITORY

Heinz has written off the dissident's nominees as neither independent nor particularly qualified, though three independent proxy advisory firms have thought enough of Trian's slate to recommend voting for one or more of its five nominees. Trian claims the current board doesn't have enough "skin in the game" to really care and that Trian investors as a group own more than 15 times as many shares of the company as Heinz's executive officers and board combined.

 ISSUE 2: Shareholder returns

HEINZ

Advertise with us

The company claims to have returned more than $4.2 billion to shareholders over the last four years in the form of annual dividends, share repurchases and a dividend linked to the divestiture of some brands to Del Monte Foods. In June, the company announced it would increase the dividend to $1.40 for the current fiscal year and spend another $1 billion on share repurchases over the next two years.

TRIAN

The challengers note that Heinz stock had dropped from $54.50 in April 1998 to $33.70 in February, although they concede that figure is not adjusted for dividends or the Del Monte spinoff. Trian has said it would maintain the dividend payout ratio in the mid-50 percent range but suggested it could push stock valuation to at least $60 per share and possibly up to $81 over time. A sale of the company within 18 months could bring even higher returns, the group has said.

DISPUTED TERRITORY

Analysts have questioned whether Trian, whose challenge to management already has increased the stock price, can truly push the stock of a company playing in a sluggish food industry that much higher. Credit rating firms have questioned the impact that both sides' efforts to appease shareholders will have on Heinz's debt rating.

Advertise with us

 ISSUE 3: The vison thing

HEINZ

Management claims it took awhile to figure out the right formula but, beginning with the spinoff of several divisions to Del Monte Foods in 2002, it has figured out how to focus its attention and resources on products with solid growth potential.

TRIAN

The dissidents say their nominees have been involved in turnarounds at businesses such as American National Can and Snapple, proving their entrepreneurial skills and the advantage of fresh ideas. They said Trian's nominees will prove to be helpful to fast-food company Wendy's International despite resistance to putting them on the board.

Advertise with us

DISPUTED TERRITORY

Trian claims Heinz under Mr. Johnson's leadership has done so many restructurings and so many acquisitions and divestitures that employees haven't been able to settle down and build the business. Heinz claims Trian is waltzing in just as it completes the overhaul of the complicated global business and the hard work is starting to pay off.

 ISSUE 4: The future of a
 Pittsburgh company

HEINZ

Management already has trimmed its local base, in part by selling the soup and baby food operations on the North Side to Del Monte in 2002. Those units have since been sold again. The company continues to employ 1,200 here, including office workers Downtown and staff at a new research and development center in Marshall.

Advertise with us

TRIAN

The dissident group has said it will not move Heinz headquarters out of Pittsburgh where there is an established core of experienced workers but it has indicated jobs likely will be trimmed. The group has said it will be a long-term participant, as proven by the fact that investors in its funds have made commitments as long as three years.

DISPUTED TERRITORY

The involvement of Mr. Peltz and Mr. May in numerous businesses has been followed by the sale of those operations later, sometimes quickly. Those men noted they have stuck with Arby's franchisor Triarc Cos. for more than a decade.

 ISSUE 5: Recommendations
 from proxy advisers

Advertise with us

HEINZ

The company hasn't fared well with the four major proxy advisory firms, which offer recommendations to big-money institutional investors on which way to vote in proxy contests. While one firm backed Heinz's entire slate of 12 nominees, the others threw their support to one or more of the five dissidents on Trian's slate. Heinz did get a boost Thursday when the influential California Public Employees Retirement System, or Calpers, threw its support and roughly 1.7 million shares behind the company's slate.

TRIAN

Mr. Peltz drew the most support of any Trian nominee, getting a thumbs up from three of the four big proxy advisers. Mr. Weinstein won the backing of two firms, while Mr. Norman got the nod from one. The two other nominees received no support. The gist is that electing one or two dissidents to the board could help hold management's feet to the fire but installing too many could be disruptive and potentially damaging to shareholder interests.

DISPUTED TERRITORY

Advertise with us

For individual shareholders, complicated voting procedures make following the advisory firms' advice to split votes difficult. Any proxy cards not filled out correctly will be thrown out. If shareholders realize they made a mistake, or simply keep changing their minds, they can cast their votes again, up until the final tally at Heinz's annual meeting on Wednesday. For shareholders who vote multiple times, the last proxy card postmarked, or the last vote placed by phone or online, will be the one that counts.

Keith Srakocic, Associated Press

Click photo for larger image.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.