Some believe that Gov. Ed Rendell's Plan B for funding a new hockey arena in Pittsburgh may be vital to his hopes of holding on to his job. Lose the Penguins, lose southwestern Pennsylvania, lose his re-election campaign.
But what really may swing the race with presumptive Republican challenger Lynn Swann has little to do with a new arena and everything to do with a matter of far more importance in the Pittsburgh area -- jobs.
Chart
Pittsburgh Employment: Back on growth track
Indeed, how the region's economy is doing come time for voters to pull the levers -- or push the buttons, or whatever it is they are going to do -- in November's general election could well determine if we'll be putting "ex-" or "two-term" in front of Mr. Rendell's title.
The fact is, southwestern Pennsylvania is coming off its worst slump since Big Steel's decline. The seven-county area eked out job gains last year for the first time since 2001, and while prospects have picked up this year, it still won't be enough to overcome a three-year string of job losses totaling more than 20,000.
It's no wonder that Mr. Rendell has spent the better part of the past three months handing out handshakes and state subsidies at company and plant expansions that promise more jobs. Nothing says, "I'm working on it" better than a picture in the newspaper, a video clip on the television news and an audio clip on the radio at a ribbon-cutting or groundbreaking.
It helps that the governor -- no stranger to the "It's the economy, stupid" mantra that guided the Clinton-Gore campaigns, the latter of which he spent as chair of the Democratic National Committee -- established with state lawmakers a big kitty to be used to help along projects in the state. Sure, he's doing state business, but, during an election year, it's akin to another campaign fund.
And it's not just money that gets Mr. Rendell out front on economic development issues. He also has the power of the bully pulpit that comes as chief executive of the nation's sixth most populous state, a pulpit he used on Friday when he announced in the Strip District that AT&T was reconsidering an earlier decision to close a call center there and transfer jobs out of a New Castle service center -- moves that would affect some 250 jobs.
But it's debatable if all this public posturing will amount to much if the rubber doesn't meet the road -- that is, if the overall jobs picture locally doesn't improve enough to make people feel that things really are getting significantly better. The Pittsburgh region has been the state's laggard on the jobs front for some time now, and the situation doesn't appear to be changing.
The numbers tell the story. The metropolitan areas of Philadelphia, Harrisburg-Lebanon, York, Lancaster, Scranton/Wilkes-Barre, State College, Johnstown and Erie all are expected to experience substantially stronger job growth this year than the Pittsburgh region, according to the latest projections from the economics team at PNC Financial Services Group.
The Pittsburgh-based bank is forecasting local businesses will add about 11,000 workers this year, up 1 percent from 2005. That compares with a projected increase of some 44,000 in Philadelphia, a 1.8 percent jump that comes on top of a gain of 24,000 -- or 1 percent -- last year. By comparison, Pittsburgh's nonfarm employment rose an estimated 3,300 in 2005, a meager 0.3 percent increase.
The jobs outlook in Philadelphia and the southeastern part of the state bodes well for Mr. Rendell in his stronghold. But he'll need strong support in Pittsburgh, too, if the center of the state follows past patterns and votes heavily Republican. That may not be a sure bet this time around, but it's not a strategic gamble that the governor can afford to take.
The governor realizes he needs to do everything he can in the region to shore up confidence in his economic stewardship, which is why you'll likely see a lot more of him in upcoming months as he makes every groundbreaking and ribbon-cutting he can. An IssuesPA/Pew poll released last week showed Mr. Swann with a slight edge over Mr. Rendell in fall's race, in part because southwestern Pennsylvania's confidence in the governor had slipped below 50 percent.
A report last week from consultant and former Allegheny Conference on Community Development President Harold Miller did note that amid the overall decline, jobs in the region did grow in such high-wage areas as higher education, health care and technology. But it also noted the gains were dwarfed by declines in transportation and manufacturing.
Many workers in these fields have proven in recent years to be so-called Reagan Democrats -- they maintain Democrat registration but vote Republican, particularly if they feel economically disenfranchised. It doesn't help that these also represent stereotypical shot-and-a-beer types who may just find Mr. Swann appealing for the simple reason he is a former Steelers great. The Hall of Fame receiver received his strongest reviews in the IssuesPA/Pew poll in the region where he made a name and home for himself.
Sure, a failure by Mr. Rendell to act on an arena could deal a blow to his re-election bid. But the final score may well depend on whether the region, when it comes to jobs, considers 2006 to be a winner or a loser.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.