When Vance LaVelle left PNC Financial Services Group in late July, the high-ranking executive attended a small party at PNC's Downtown Pittsburgh headquarters, complete with cake and cookies, offered an emotional farewell to her colleagues and headed for home.

A home that was more than 300 miles away.

In the New York metro area.

One of the highest-ranking women at PNC, LaVelle was an extreme commuter -- flying into Pittsburgh at the beginning of the work week, staying several nights at the Duquesne Club and catching commercial flights back to New York or New Jersey at the end of the week. The ex-chief marketing officer, who came to PNC from New York-based JP Morgan Chase, did that week after week and stayed at the bank for five years.

Advertise with us

As it turns out, logistically challenging commutes are not uncommon at the highest reaches of PNC, the region's largest bank and employer of more than 7,000 people locally. LaVelle is gone, but at least four other top PNC executives still work in Downtown Pittsburgh during the week, staying in apartments and hotel rooms, and then travel great distances to more permanent homes at the end of the week, according to sources close to PNC.

The habits of PNC's supercommuters touch on the sensitive topic of how Pittsburgh is perceived nationally. It remains difficult, local headhunters said, to bring in top-line executive talent, especially in banking, when much of the action still takes place in New York.

"Pittsburgh is not the center of the universe in banking," said local recruiter Tom Flannery, managing director of the Pittsburgh area office for Boyden Global Executive Search. "As a consequence, the Pittsburgh banks will go to the center of the universe, which is New York, and recruit the best people they can find.

"If the talent you recruit doesn't wish to relocate, do you go out and look for lesser talent, or do you accommodate that individual?" Flannery asked.

'It's a Pittsburgh thing'

Advertise with us

The long -- and no doubt expensive -- commutes also are the subject of some debate within PNC, a company led by longtime Pittsburgh booster James E. Rohr. Some in senior management have expressed frustration with the practice, according to sources close to the bank, and some rank-and-file employees also are rankled by it, believing it is a questionable expense at a time when PNC is carrying out a $300 million cost-cutting campaign and paring 3,000 positions over two years.

Some at the bank argue that if PNC can't recruit people to live in Pittsburgh, it should not hire them. Others maintain that it is too difficult to recruit talented people to live and work here, especially executives who hail from larger, more urbane East Coast cities.

"It's the Pittsburgh thing," said one source close to PNC.

Top bank officers, the source said, "can't convince people to move to Pittsburgh or can't convince themselves that they can convince people to move to Pittsburgh."

The bank has had success in luring some East Coast executives to live and work in Pittsburgh. Vice Chairman William Demchak, for example, came to PNC from New York's JP Morgan in 2002. The bank's new chief financial officer, Richard Johnson, also is from JP Morgan. In fact, most of the people who report directly to Rohr live in the Pittsburgh area.

Advertise with us

But there also are several high-profile executives who would prefer to hang their pinstripes elsewhere.

General Counsel Helen Pudlin, the bank's highest-ranking woman, and Executive Vice President Neil Hall both commute from the Philadelphia area. Pudlin keeps a place at a Gateway Center residential tower, and Hall stays often at the Omni William Penn, according to two sources close to PNC.

Senior Vice President Matt Carter, who is in charge of advertising and branding, flies in from San Diego, according to one PNC source, and has stayed at the Duquesne Club. Bill Mutterperl, another vice chairman, also has stayed at the venerable city club on Sixth Avenue while in town during the week, according to several sources.

Mutterperl, hired in 2002 to handle corporate governance issues after PNC's accounting practices ran afoul of regulators that year, appears to be the only executive reporting directly to Rohr, the chairman and CEO, who commutes from outside the region. A PNC spokesman declined to provide the location of Mutterperl's permanent home, but before joining PNC Mutterperl was a partner with a law firm in Boston and chief general counsel for FleetBoston Financial Corp.

In the case of Mutterperl and the other supercommuters, it's not known if the company pays for all temporary living arrangements. Flannery, the local headhunter, said it was typical for companies to cover the costs of traveling back and forth once or twice a month, but was rarer to cover such costs week to week.

Advertise with us

What exactly is paid for (hotel rooms, plane tickets, meals) also may vary from employee to employee. But Flannery also pointed out that in some cases a permanent relocation could be more expensive than a temporary week-to-week arrangement, with permanent relocation packages for top executives running as high as $200,000 -- covering the cost of real estate commissions on large homes and other moving expenses.

"Relocation is very expensive," Flannery said. And, "People don't want to uproot their families .... As a consequence, [the supercommute] works."

A PNC spokesman did not want to disclose the details of executives who live elsewhere.

"We have supported flexible work arrangements for years," said PNC spokesman Brian Goerke. "I don't feel it would be appropriate to comment in specific individuals' situations."

'We need to be here'

Advertise with us

PNC is not the only company in town with supercommuters. Downtown-based investment management firm Federated Investors also scours Wall Street for talent and is willing to accommodate people who would rather live elsewhere. Like PNC, Federated did not want to comment on the practice.

"The couple folks we do have would prefer not to be mentioned in the article," a Federated spokeswoman said.

Education Management Corp., a secondary school operator based Downtown, is led by a chief executive officer who spends several days a week in a Pittsburgh-area apartment before returning to more permanent homes in Portland, Maine, or Washington, D.C. The CEO, John McKernan, a former governor of Maine who is married to Sen. Olympia Snowe, R-Maine, was unavailable for comment last week about his commuting habits, according to a company spokesman.

Aluminum giant Alcoa Inc. is another big local company whose top executives have permanent homes elsewhere -- mostly in the New York area. Except, in Alcoa's case, the top brass does not commute to Pittsburgh. Some may travel back and forth for meetings, but if they live in New York, they work in New York, said company spokesman Kevin Lowery.

The fact that so many top executives, including Chairman Alain Belda, who sold his Shadyside home years ago, live in New York has prompted speculation that the company's true headquarters is actually on Manhattan's Park Avenue, where Alcoa leases space in the landmark Lever House. The company maintains that its headquarters is on the North Side, at the Alcoa Corporate Center, a $67 million complex that opened in 1998 along the Allegheny River.

Advertise with us

Speaking about the headquarters issue, Lowery said, "People need to get over it."

But a deeper look at Alcoa's 11-member executive council shows that only one of the top officers -- Vice President and Chief Technical Officer Mohammad Zaidi -- lives and works in the Pittsburgh area. Seven of the 11 live and work in the New York area and an eighth -- Vice President Ruth Mack -- lives in Virginia and works in New York. The remaining two live in Cleveland and Switzerland.

Not all big companies have problems persuading top execs to live and work here. Former H.J. Heinz Co. general counsel Laura Stein commuted to Pittsburgh from San Francisco for five years before quitting in January to take a similar post with Clorox Co. in Oakland, Calif. Now, no top executives at the Pittsburgh ketchup company endure such long commutes, according to company spokesman Deb Foster.

"The company does encourage people to live here," she said.

PPG Industries, U.S. Steel, Dick's Sporting Goods and Nova Chemicals Corp. all said their executive teams were entirely based in the Pittsburgh area. "When people come to work for U.S. Steel, they come to work here for a long period of time," said U.S. Steel spokesman John Armstrong. "This is where they make their homes."

Advertise with us

Among the region's other major banks, Mellon Financial Corp. could not be reached for comment. Two others with corporate headquarters elsewhere were quick to point out that all local executives in charge of regional operations live here.

"We live and work in our hometown communities," said Bill Eihler, spokesman for National City Bank of Pennsylvania. National City, the market's No. 2 bank, is based in Cleveland.

Added Mike Jones, spokesman for Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania: "We are an organization that operates locally with local decision-making and local executives."

The larger Citizens is based in Providence, R.I., and the head of Pennsylvania operations is based in the Philadelphia area.

But those in charge of the western part of the state all live here, he said.

"We feel to be able to serve our customers appropriately we need to be here," Jones said.