Michael Gross, the chairman and chief executive of Apollo Investment Corp., with four children and facing middle age, took up running in 2000. He loved it so much he ran in the next four New York City marathons and dropped 25 pounds in the process. So he knows something about new ventures and perseverance.
Apollo Investment is the publicly traded affiliate of well-known private-equity firm Apollo Advisors, which Mr. Gross helped found with Leon Black and others in 1990. Apollo Advisors has invested about $12 billion buying out, turning around and flipping underperforming public companies. Its annual returns have averaged more than 40 percent.
Despite that first-rate pedigree, Apollo Investment's beginnings as a public company were inauspicious. The stock fell 15 percent after its initial public offering in April 2004, trading below the value of its assets for a period. "It was pretty demoralizing," says Mr. Gross.
Investors felt at the time that what was good for Apollo wasn't good for them. They were concerned about the high fees charged by the outside investment manager for Apollo Investment's portfolio. That entity is also an Apollo Advisors affiliate, called Apollo Investment Management. Keeping it all straight?
Apollo Investment had been caught in a wave of worry, which continues today, over whether there is a bubble in hedge funds and private-equity firms -- and whether they are being dangerously peddled to small investors. Was this private-equity firm for the little guy simply a scheme to separate individual investors from their money?
Sure, anything on offer from Wall Street is sure to be good for Wall Street. But amid this line of criticism, the notion that small investors were beginning to have access to some of the world's best money managers got lost. Investors in Apollo Investment have some advantages over Apollo Advisors' deep-pocketed investors. They can get in and out any time, just by buying and selling their stock. And while the return expectation is lower, they take on less risk to invest alongside the big boys.
"These guys are smart, as smart as they come, quite frankly. Their investment experience is very strong," says Eric Brock, portfolio manager for money manager Clough Capital, which owns more than $10 million in Apollo Investment stock.
Apollo Investment expands Apollo Advisors' bailiwick beyond private equity. The public company mostly lends to smaller companies in a variety of industries, from auto parts to advertising, taking positions in between a bank, which is the senior lender, and the equity holders, and then targeting a return in the low-to-mid teens. Since the firm is constituted as a business-development corporation, it has tax advantages as long as it distributes most of its income as dividends.
After the company went public, many private-equity firms, large and small, rushed to do the same. But when Apollo Investment's stock stumbled, most of the other IPOs fell through.
This year's a different story. Apollo Investment's stock has performed strongly, especially compared with the overall market. It's up 22 percent this year. The shares' total return, including dividends, has been 24.4 percent, assuming the $15 IPO purchase price.
Investors have warmed to its strategy, as Apollo Investment has been productive in finding good companies in need of cash. After trading at a discount to its assets, it now trades around 1.25 times book value. And after fully investing its IPO proceeds of $930 million, it can borrow an additional $800 million, leverage that could boost future returns. Suntrust Robinson Humphrey's Carl Drake expects that its dividend will rise significantly in a couple of years.
The advantages for Apollo Advisors to have such a public vehicle are clear. The public markets provide cheaper capital at any time. But it comes at a risk. Apollo Investments is toiling in a different field than its well-known affiliate, and if that goes barren, Apollo Advisors could take a hit to its reputation and its ability to raise private-equity funds.
To buy Apollo Investment stock, one has to have faith in management and the board. The management company manages Apollo Investment's money for a steep price -- a 2 percent management fee and then 20 percent of any gains, if the public company makes at least a 7 percent return on equity.
"It's a tremendous amount of compensation for that amount of return," says Rose DiMartino, Wilkie Farr & Gallagher partner who specializes in similarly structured companies.
But investors might consider how appealing the transparency of that fee structure is, especially with so much hidden executive compensation and other expenses at many companies.
"For an investor, there will be no surprises on the expenses," says Mr. Gross, who is compensated through Apollo Investment Management, not the public company. "You are not going to see outlandish bonuses, or that we hired 30 new people, or that there was a big grant of stock options."
Another concern is the inherent conflict of the fee structure. The managers might be inclined to sell their winners to reap the fees, while sitting on its losers. Critics have levied exactly that charge against Allied Capital, another business development company with a slightly different management structure. I wrote about one such case for Allied back in September. Allied denies the charge.
Of course, it's early to deem Apollo Investment a success. It has only been investing as interest rates have stayed peculiarly low, resulting in a benign credit environment. "It's early days. It's tough to judge our performance," Mr. Gross says. "But the performance has been much better than expected."
Such an endeavor is a marathon, not a sprint.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.