On eastbound Interstate 70 in Pennsylvania, not far from the West Virginia border, a billboard urges drivers to check out Ace Sporting Goods, a firearms dealer that claims to have served Western Pennsylvania hunters for more than half a century.

Robin Rombach, Post-Gazette

Todd Mueller handles human resources at Cabela's new distribution center in West Virginia, about five miles from the Pennsylvania state line. A Cabela's store will open on an adjacent site Aug. 12.

Click photo for larger image.

Advertise with us

Ace owner George Romanoff doesn't generally do many billboards, but then his South Strabane store isn't always heading into what may be the perfect firestorm.

Within a month, a 175,000-square-foot Cabela's outdoor store will open just off a new interstate exit less than five miles from the Pennsylvania border and adjacent to Cabela's massive distribution center. Not to be outdone, Pennsylvania officials are negotiating to put a Bass Pro Shops Outdoor World store just off Interstate 79, near the Meadows racetrack and a proposed outlet mall. Romanoff figures the store would be about two miles from his place.

"This area's really a great location," the Ace Sporting Goods store owner said, resignedly.

Indeed, while a Bass Pro spokesman wasn't ready to say the company wants to be specifically at the South Strabane site, he did say this neck of the woods sure looks tempting to a retailer selling hunting, fishing and camping gear. "I was hoping we'd have been there a long time ago," said Larry Whiteley.

Nationally, the market for hunting and camping gear has been uneven, but apparently there are still plenty of camouflage-draped drivers seeking the great outdoors along Interstates 70 and 79.

Advertise with us

If the region's residents make outdoor chains drool, then these two outdoor chains and their really, really big stores' track records have the same effect on government types.

Earlier versions of the massive stores have established track records as tourist destinations that pull millions of visitors in to see their stuffed bears, tigers and deer, their aquariums and gun shops, not to mention eat at their restaurants.

Bass Pro claims its Springfield, Mo., shop is that state's biggest tourist attraction. The only Pennsylvania Cabela's, which opened in Hamburg, Berks County, in September, drew an estimated 3.5 million visitors in its first four months.

That, plus the promise of a colossal Cabela's distribution center to serve the East Coast, was enough to get West Virginia to fry up a package of incentives that the state's development office estimated will be worth a $93 million over 10 years, including tax incentives, infrastructure improvements, grants and that new interstate exit. In return, the state's cost-benefit analysis calculated the public would collect $98.6 million in various property and payroll taxes from the project over that same period.

Pennsylvania came up with millions in incentives to get Cabela's to Hamburg and a Bass Pro that's planned for Harrisburg. It's likely to take more than of $20 million to get a Bass Pro for Washington County.

Advertise with us

State Rep. Tim Solobay is so convinced the outdoor store will be an economic generator that he called the governor's office to protect his district's position as the chosen location after hearing Armstrong and Westmoreland officials might be angling to take it away.

He's hoping everyone from state to county to school officials back the project, which would likely require deferring some tax revenues for several years. "I just hope we don't lose an opportunity of a lifetime," said Solobay.

He concedes the arrival of the monster stores may be hard on businesses such as Ace Sporting Goods, Gander Mountain and Dick's Sporting Goods, but he's counting on the influx of visitors to add customers to the overall market and spur other development on land near the stores.

The Washington County Tourism Promotion Agency is working to exploit Cabela's opening. In August, the agency expects to send information to travel writers to get them to visit and then publicize the region's appeal.

Mark Tallarico, the agency's executive director, is fascinated by stories such as those from his brother-in-law in Tennessee who drove to the Cabela's in Dundee, Mich., spent three or four days there and more than $5,000 on tents, crossbows and other gear.

Advertise with us

If the two competitors do set up camp 25 miles away from each other, it will be an experiment in whether or not the herds of consumers here are big enough to feed both. "They're running out of room as far as locations where they're not in the same marketplace," said Lee Diercks, a sporting goods industry consultant with Clear Thinking Group in Hillsborough, N.J.

Cabelas, based in Sidney, Neb., has nine stores open, with plans for three more by next year. Missouri-based Bass Pro has 21 with plans for at least 13 more.

Cabela's will have the head start here once its West Virginia store opens Aug. 12. Already 450 retail employees have been hired and begun training.

Just as significant is the new distribution center tucked out of sight behind the store. Inside, boxes of tree stands, turkey fryers and duck decoys are stacked up, but most of the cavernous place is echoes with emptiness. A trickle of, maybe, 10 packages a day is being shipped from the place that could theoretically hold 13 football fields.

By year-end, almost 300 workers, generally starting at $8 an hour, will be punching nine time clocks as trucks roll up to 47 docks ready for pickup and deliveries of fishing rods, kayaks and arrows.

Advertise with us

Cabela's claims to be the largest mail-order, retail and Internet outfitter in the world. Almost 70 percent of its combined direct and retail sales in fiscal 2003 came from the direct side.

Its two other shipping centers, in Nebraska and Wisconsin, are overloaded and ready to dump some of the workload here. There's room for another almost 600,000-square-foot building on the site, said Todd Mueller, who handles human resources for the distribution center.

Just how the outdoor sporting goods market will shake out, locally and nationally, remains to be seen.

Cabela's recently went public and there's talk Bass Pro may follow. Minneapolis-based Gander Mountain went public in April. Findlay-based Dick's Sporting Goods, which went public in late 2002, has said it needs to focus more attention on the outdoor segment, in addition to its sneakers, golf gear and other sports staples.

At Ace Sporting Goods, Romanoff is bracing himself. He's doesn't think it's fair when his big competitors get help from the government yet he's happy to see these companies raising awareness of the industry.

Advertise with us

He points out that, while the region may be filled with hunters and fishermen, it's also losing population overall. "The bottom line is the pie is only so big and it's a shrinking pie."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.