The COVID-19 pandemic will be forever known as the great disruptor.

For many nonprofits, it might have been the final chapter except for the agile efforts of dedicated staffs and volunteers moving fundraisers from in-person to virtual and then sometimes to a hybrid middle ground.

The four Carnegie Museums reopened to the public after the initial 15-week COVID closure and have remained open with the exception of the statewide closure during December 2020.

“Our experience has been much different than the experiences of performing arts groups, many of whom remained closed throughout 2020 and well into 2021,” noted Betsy Momich, museums spokeswoman.

Advertise with us

Still, virtual offerings — including tours of exhibits and conversations with curators and scientists — have become a popular feature and are likely to stick around.

“During the initial COVID-19 closure in the spring of 2020, our museums created an incredibly diverse batch of virtual programs and events — including members-only virtual experiences that we’ve continued to offer since our museums reopened to the public in the summer of 2020,” said Yvonne Maher, vice president of advancement and community engagement at Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh.

“Last year and this year, virtual programming has been most critical in our support of teachers and their students,” Ms. Maher said. “Online programming is going to remain an important part of our outreach to schools, and a potentially growing source of revenue for our museums.”

The hybrid future

Ronald McDonald House Charities was one of the organizations that made a quick pivot to save the bottom line and the people who count on the assistance.

Advertise with us

“Fortunately, the charity was able to host its annual golf outing as it took place outside,” said Amy Rayman, development director. The organization did, however, transition its Red Shoe Ball to a virtual event since it has traditionally been held inside.

“It’s challenging to compare year over year as they were both very unique,” she noted. “I can share that the 2021 golf outing grossed somewhere in the neighborhood of a bit more than $100,000, but we did not have an outing in 2020 due to the pandemic.”

The 2020 Red Shoe Ball raised about $25,000 with an online auction. “And while the ball wasn’t in person, the addition of a live streamed program this year helped create a community vibe and celebrated the notion... that we may be ‘worlds apart, but close at heart!’” she explained. The organization worked with Fireside Events in Allison Park to put together the ball, which overall raised a little over $100,000.

By offering a live program this year, they were able to conduct the Sponsor a Family ask, which raised additional money. “It  is always well-received by our supporters and accounted for somewhere around $20,000 in revenue,” she said.

“It’s a bit early to know for sure what 2022 will look like, exactly, but I do suspect that there will be a hybrid approach for the Ball.” Ms. Rayman said.

Advertise with us

Fighting Zoom fatigue

“To sustain our donor community during periods of social isolation and distancing, we had to look for new ways to maintain connections and build upon existing relationships through technology,” said Michael Braxton, director of development at the Pittsburgh Opera.

Currently the Pittsburgh Opera’s virtual fundraising is limited to activities such as online auctions and Giving Tuesday/Give Big Pittsburgh event.

“We are not planning another virtual gala since we are able to have in-person ones,” said Chris Cox, director of marketing and communications.

“In terms of whether in-person vs. virtual generates more excitement, I’d say they both generate excitement, but in different ways,” added Mr. Cox.

Advertise with us

This year opera supporters attended the Diamond Horseshoe Dinner. It was a smaller, more intimate affair in place of the traditionally larger Diamond Horseshoe Ball. And it served as a way to ease into in-person events again. Prior to this year’s dinner, the opera had a week-long, exclusively online auction component.

“It did well in place of the live auction and in-person silent auction,” said Mr. Braxton.

“In November 2021, overall, I think the allure of virtual galas is waning,” admitted Mr. Cox. “Zoom fatigue has set in for many people.”

Still, some combination of both seems to be the future of fundraising in general. The Pittsburgh Opera saw higher attendance at virtual board events and other volunteer and donor cultivation engagements during the early months of the pandemic.

“We will move forward with hybrid virtual and in-person options and will continue to engage donors, both in person and virtually,” said Mr. Braxton.

Advertise with us

That said, the Pittsburgh Opera’s May 2020 virtual Maecenas gala was an important way to maintain engagement with many patrons while the country was locked down by COVID.

“Fundraising is about connecting with donors and building relationships between them and the opera and that was true before the pandemic and will always continue to be so,” Mr. Braxton said.

Patricia Sheridan: psheridan@post-gazette.com