Like many seasoned travelers, Pittsburgh native Andrea Weigl planned to stay in a local hotel when she traveled here from Raleigh, N.C., just after New Year’s for her mother’s 80th birthday party.

Her mom doesn’t drive, and Ms. Weigl wanted to be close to her home in West View in case the family had to transport her to the restaurant. Then a flight got cancelled, necessitating a third night of accommodations in the city.

Extending her reservation at the Hampton Inn on McKnight Road would have cost an additional $141. Instead, she booked an apartment at Heinz Lofts on Airbnb.

Even with mandatory cleaning and service fees tacked on, the Pittsburgh native ended up getting more for her money in more ways than one: Not only was the three-day home stay in the two-bedroom North Side apartment easier on the pocketbook and more comfortable for her family of three — it cost $343.64, compared to the $322.73 she would have paid for a two-night stay in a king suite at the hotel — but it also offered a more authentic (and convenient) Pittsburgh experience.

Advertise with us

The Strip District is a must-visit spot on trips back home, Ms. Weigl said, and the apartment just across the Allegheny River was within easy walking distance. “It just works better for our family,” she said.

Airbnb is making it easier to scratch one’s travel itch for a whole lot of other people, too.

The San Francisco-based vacation home rental company that started with just a handful of units in 2010 now boasts some 7 million listings in more than 220 countries. To date, it’s generated more than 500 million bookings.

The locations in which people are staying has similarly multiplied. Ten years ago, close to 90% of all guest arrivals were at listings in the company’s 10 biggest markets, including New York and Los Angeles. Today, more than 900 cities have at least 1,000 Airbnb listings each, according to Liz DeBold, senior communications manager, U.S.-East for Airbnb.

That includes Pittsburgh, where, as of Jan. 1, there are 2,500 active listings.

Advertise with us

A papal push

Kitty Vagley and Jeff Neubauer became hosts in 2016, after fixing up a former glass factory built in 1891.

They’d originally planned on flipping a property located next door to their rowhouse on South 17th Street in the South Side Slopes. But they spent so much money (and elbow grease) on the renovation that there was no way they’d make a return on their investment. “And we just didn’t have the heart to turn it over to people for rental,” Ms. Vagley said.

The fact they live next door made the venture feel less risky — as did the fact that the three-bedroom house, which rents for between $200-$300 a night, appeals more to families than couples or singletons. “And Airbnb made it so easy,” said Mr. Neubauer, noting that they had their first listing in less than a week.

The Pennsylvania market for the company started to grow around the papal visit to Philadelphia in 2015, when hotel rooms were in short supply. It has continued its growth, Ms. DeBold said, because the company directly benefits an entire community.

Advertise with us

Pa. Airbnb host income and guest arrivals, 2019 Hover over each county to see host income and guests hosted. Counties are ranked by host income.

Source: Airbnb.com

Ed Yozwick/Post-Gazette

Travelers love vacation rental sites because they support tourism that is local, authentic, diverse, inclusive and sustainable, plus it’s often cheaper than a hotel. Hosts, who pay Airbnb 3% for each booking made through the site, appreciate the extra cash in their pockets — some $20 million in supplemental income in Allegheny County alone in 2019, based on 174,200 guest arrivals.

It also generates income for local economies. Airbnb guests typically spend 41% of their travel dollars in the neighborhood where they stay, Ms. DeBold said. And they pump hundreds of thousands of dollars into municipal coffers in the form of taxes.

Advertise with us

“We’re proud to have a very good working relationship with Pennsylvania officials,” she said, collecting and remitting taxes on city, county and state levels beginning in July 2015. 

A competitive challenge

Which is not to say those in the hotel business are exactly thrilled with the idea of short-term rentals, or that they should underestimate the influence companies like Airbnb and competitors HomeAway and VRBO have had on the industry, said Jerad Bachar, executive vice president and interim CEO of Visit Pittsburgh.

More than ever, he said, consumers are looking for unique travel experiences, “and we have to deliver.”

Even though the vast majority of travelers (70%) still opt for traditional accommodations in hotels, motels and bed-and-breakfasts, “It’s made it a much more competitive market for everyone,” he said, especially as the number of hotel rooms in the region has grown by 14% over the last five years.

Advertise with us

“It’s new inventory, so there’s some competition there,” agreed John Graf, president and CEO of Priory Hospitality Group, which owns the Priory Hotel, Mansions on Fifth and the soon-to-open Workingmen’s Square Hotel on East Ohio Street, and also is redeveloping the Westinghouse Castle in Wilmerding.

“If you’re a hotelier, you need to be thinking about how to deal with it” by adding value to your service and embracing the concept, he said.

Part of it is offering concierge services, such as providing advice about restaurants, attractions and walking tours. “Our center city shuttle is a big hit,” Mr. Graf noted, as are the hotel’s Rivers Casino and Explore the North Shore packages, which includes tickets to the Warhol Museum, National Aviary and other places to see.

Last year, hotels and motels in the Pittsburgh region boasted an occupancy rate of 63.5%, just a few points below the national rate of 66.1%, according to STR, an Ohio-based global hotel data tracker.

Airbnb’s occupancy rate for the same period was 54%, with seniors one of the fastest growing segments, especially those traveling with children. Female solo travelers are also on the rise.

Advertise with us

What some people might not realize, Ms. DeBold noted, is that many of Airbnb’s listings aren’t actually homes but boutique hotels looking to reach a larger customer base. “This is not an either/or situation,” she said.

Weighing the costs

While there’s often a cost advantage to staying in an Airbnb, that’s not always the case. Mr. Bachar noted that hotel rooms in Pittsburgh are averaging $114 a night, compared to $122 a night for a home stay. Most properties listed on Airbnb, in fact, include cleaning and other fees that customers don’t see until they book the stay, and substantially raise the cost of the trip.

He conceded travelers tend to get more space and amenities with Airbnb, “so there is an argument to be made for its value.”

Ms. Weigl said staying in an Airbnb allowed her to spend more of her tourism dollars eating out and shopping in the Strip District. Between all her visits to thrift stores and stocking up on supplies at the many international grocery stores and retail shops on Penn Avenue, she had to borrow a piece of luggage to get it all home.

Advertise with us

Mr. Neubauer said he and his wife, both retirees, have welcomed travelers from as far away as China, Denmark and South Africa in the four years they’ve been hosting.

Many are repeat customers, such as a group of eight men who come each summer to attend Steelers training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe. “They all sit out in the back yard, smoking cigars and cooking on the grill,” he said — an experience that would be difficult if not impossible to replicate in a traditional hotel.

A binder full of restaurant and pub recommendations that he and his wife have pulled together for guests is always at the ready, helping to boost business at neighborhood restaurants. Like many hotels, they also direct visitors to cultural activities such as museums and local attractions like Fallingwater.

Hosting is hard work, with lots of laundry, Mr. Neubauer said, but he takes pride in the fact that they’re adding to Pittsburgh’s travel industry. The experience also has helped the couple better feel the pulse of their city and neighborhood.

“It makes you more aware of what’s going on, and you develop some great relationships,” he said.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.