Every so often, someone gets worked up about a Securities and Exchange Commission regulation that gives insiders more opportunities to sell shares without being accused of insider trading.
Two years ago, it was the Council of Institutional Investors that asked the SEC to issue clearer guidance on the rule, called 10b5-1 for the section of the regulation adopted in 2000.
Under 10b5-1 plans, officers, directors and other insiders who don’t have material, nonpublic information about their company’s prospects can establish a plan for selling a set amount of shares over a certain time period and within certain price limits.
Once the plan is established, the shares are turned over to someone like a broker or investment adviser who follows the instructions laid out in the plan. Since the insider no longer has a say in the matter, he or she has a defense against charges of insider trading.
The plans were authorized because officers and directors frequently have material information, which makes it hard for them to sell stock — to diversify their portfolios, pay for their children’s college expenses or make major purchases — without being accused of insider trading.
Critics have some issues with the plans. Insiders generally do not disclose when they file the plans or the terms. The plans are not filed with the SEC. Moreover, insiders can amend or terminate the plans. Collectively, these features raise questions about whether insiders are really in the dark when they adopt the plans.
“The SEC hates them,” said Ernest Badway, a securities lawyer with Fox Rothschild in New York. “They just see it as a recipe for insider trading.”
Concerns were fueled by research that revealed insiders do remarkably well when they trade under the cover of 10b5-1 plans. Here’s what then-Stanford University accounting professor Alan Jagolinzer discovered when he looked at about 3,400 insiders at 1,200 companies who disclosed stock sale plans between October 2000 and December 2005.
Executives who sold through 10b5-1 plans beat the market by 6 percent over the subsequent six months. Executives who didn’t rely on the plans beat the market by only 1.9 percent.
Additionally, when executives terminated their 10b5-1 plan — something SEC regulations permits them to do — the price of their shares subsequently rose a meaningful number of times, according to Mr. Jagolinzer, who now teaches at the University of Colorado.
Spurred by Wall Street Journal stories that highlighted instances where insiders were abiding by the letter of the rule but maybe not the spirit, the Council of Institutional Investors asked the SEC to tighten things up a bit in late 2012.
The questions the stories raised included 10b5-1 trades that occurred just prior to company news announcements and the number of times insiders cancelled the plans, indicating that perhaps they were not acting in good faith when they adopted them. Mr. Jagolinzer’s findings about what happened to stock prices after terminations supported that suggestion.
The council, which represents pension funds, asked the SEC to only allow insiders to adopt 10b5-1 plans during the limited trading windows when companies allow insiders to conduct most of their transactions, generally in between quarterly earnings announcements.
It also recommended that insiders not be able to make frequent amendments to the plans or terminate them often. Finally, the council said there should be at least a 30-day delay between the time an insider adopts a plan and the first trade made under the plan.
The group wrote another letter to SEC Chairman Mary Jo White five months later reiterating its recommendations. Thus far, the agency has not taken any action.
Law firms recommend many of the practices the council was seeking. Skadden, Arps, for example, advised using a holding period between adopting a plan and the first sale. The firm also cautioned that company decisions on when to disclose material information should be made without considering whether any 10b5-1 plans are in play.
Mr. Badway advises that clients who adopt the plans should not amend or cancel them.
“Forget about it. Don’t interact with [the plan]. Let it just take its course,” he said.
Still, the council and Mr. Jagolinzer’s research indicate that the nagging concerns over the plans will continue. If insiders don’t abide by best practices, the SEC could decide to take a closer look.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.