The U.S. Supreme Court recently ruled on a now well-known case involving a group of New Haven, Conn., firefighters who claimed reverse discrimination when they were passed over for promotions after passing qualifying exams.

While the high court ruled in favor of the firefighters, its decision has ramifications for any employer faced with difficult decisions around compliance with two separate prohibitions regarding discrimination.

To understand what this means to employers, it is important to understand something about two types of discrimination as defined by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. They are "disparate treatment" discrimination and "disparate impact" discrimination.

The act prohibits intentional discrimination against employees based upon their race and sex, among other things.

Advertise with us

Reverse discrimination also is prohibited. This means employers cannot intentionally favor women or minorities because of their race or sex. When an employer intentionally discriminates, this is called "disparate treatment" discrimination.

Title VII also prohibits unintentional discrimination. For example, an employer who requires a high school diploma for all employees would be guilty of race discrimination if this requirement screened out significantly more minorities than Caucasians, and if not all jobs really needed a high school education.

Consider a security guard company that requires all guards be at least 6 feet tall or weigh at least 150 pounds. Such requirements might screen out a disproportionate number of females, even though the requirements may not be needed for performance of guard duties. This unintended discrimination is called "disparate impact" discrimination.

Not uncommonly, these two kinds of discrimination claims come into conflict with each other, as they did in the Supreme Court's Ricci v. DeStefano case.

The City of New Haven paid an outside vendor more than $100,000 for a professionally developed, validated test to measure the relative qualifications of candidates for promotion to lieutenant and captain in its fire department.

Advertise with us

When the test was given, white and Hispanic firefighters scored much higher than the black candidates. The Civil Service Board refused to certify the exam results because some members were concerned the city would be sued by the black firefighters on a theory of disparate impact discrimination, or unintentional discrimination.

So no one was promoted.

The high-scoring white firefighters sued, claiming intentional reverse discrimination. By now, you may be aware that they lost in the district and appeals courts, but in the end, the Supreme Court held that the city's refusal to use the test results amounted to disparate treatment or intentional race discrimination.

For employers, the issue in the Ricci case was whether an employer's concern about a disparate impact race discrimination lawsuit justified a race-conscious solution such as scrapping the test results.

Think about how the same issue can play out in common business situations, such as when a reduction in a work force results in a disproportionately high layoff of females or minorities.

Advertise with us

If the employer attempts to correct the disparate impact, it can be faced with accusations of disparate treatment or intentional reverse discrimination.

The Supreme Court's ruling said to employers that fear of a lawsuit by the low-scoring minority employees does not justify undoing a selection process, since undoing the process would be a race-based decision in and of itself.

Instead, an employer who wants to redo a decision because of its adverse impact on minorities or females must have "a strong basis in evidence" for a belief that it would lose a disparate impact lawsuit.

An employer whose initial decisions result in a statistical imbalance must assess its own actions to see whether there is "strong evidence" they were illegal. If so, it can redo the process to achieve a more balanced result. If not, it should proceed as planned and brace for a disparate impact suit.

That standard has left employers in a very difficult situation. It is not easy to decide whether the standard is met in a particular case or how a court will view the same set of facts.

Advertise with us

Should those criteria result in an adverse impact, while that gives an employer the opportunity to reconsider, in most cases the best decision will be to proceed with the selections based upon the original criteria. If they make sense in the context, it is less likely a judge will second-guess the decision.

For public employers, the Ricci decision created more issues than it resolved. The Supreme Court said it would not decide until another case whether a public employer can ever be subject to disparate impact liability, since that would require the employer to make race- or sex-conscious choices to avert liability.

Therefore, a public employer might never be permitted to adjust a decision to avoid disparate impact claims even if there is strong evidence that less discriminatory alternatives exist.

While private employers chafe under a difficult standard, public employers have been, for the time being, left without any standard at all.