As fat raindrops pounded the pavement, Logan Sky and Rylie Jade rushed through the sprawling, empty parking lot at the Mall at Robinson last week and headed inside for their regular shopping trip.
Ms. Sky, 18, halfheartedly browsed through the racks at Macy's while Ms. Jade, 19, wandered past a shuttered storefront and an almost desolate food court.
The teens browsed through band T-shirts at their favorite store, Hot Topic, before moving on to Spencer's, a store known for novelty and gag gifts, where they leafed through cardboard boxes piled with $1 items.
Hours later, they had made just one purchase: a large Starbucks frappuccino. Both women agreed they’ll be putting retail therapy on hold for now, as consumers exercise caution in the wake of tariffs imposed by President Donald Trump and the price surges that are expected to follow.
"If things are more expensive, I'm less likely to shop," Ms. Sky said between gulps of her frothy pink drink.
According to the University of Michigan’s consumer sentiment report, consumer confidence fell 11% in March, marking the fourth month of decline and an overall drop of 34% in the last year.
Read More
The slide comes as consumers report growing concerns about Trump’s escalating trade wars, inflation, job loss and a possible recession on the horizon.
"I don't think consumers are going to bounce back to normal because things aren't normal," said Duquesne University professor and economist Risa Kumazawa. "When there's uncertainty, it is obviously not a good thing for businesses."
Last week, Trump abruptly reversed course on sweeping tariffs imposed on most nations after days of turmoil in global markets sent stock indices plunging. At the same time, though, he raised the tax rate on Chinese imports to 125%. China countered by increasing levies on U.S. goods from 84% to 125%, and denounced Trump's policies as "economic bullying," the Associated Press reported.
Trump then reversed course again, announcing on Friday the administration would exclude electronics like smartphones and laptops from the reciprocal tariffs, a move that could help keep the prices down for popular consumer electronics made in China, according to the AP.
In 2024, nearly $17 billion worth of Chinese products were imported to Pennsylvania, including cell phones and computers, toys, furniture and bedding, according to the Pennsylvania Department of Community & Economic Development.
Shoppers Vance Mixter and Gino Bontempo, of Steubenville, Ohio, said they were trying to stock up on discounted clothes at the Mall at Robinson — with little luck — before deciding to limit their spending to essentials for the foreseeable future.
The pair said they already struggle to make ends meet despite working full-time.
"We don't go out to eat, we don't go get fast food a lot, we've already cut down a lot of our expenses," Mr. Mixter, 25, said. "The fact that stuff impending might get even more expensive — I'm already doing what I can."
The economic anxiety also extends to business owners, who have weathered a barrage of blows due to the rise of online shopping and the shuttering of brick-and-mortar stores caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, Ms. Kumazawa said. According to data released by Coresight Research, the number of stores closing in 2025 could double the 7,325 recorded in 2024, Scripps News reported.
"If you are a retailer, clothing store that's not doing too well, this is not going to be good news," Ms. Kumazawa said. "If they're not doing well before the tariffs kick in, they're definitely going to feel the pain."






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.