A top aide to Mayor Bill Peduto has completed “very positive” first discussions with the two developers tapped to redevelop the Strip District produce terminal but acknowledged that much work remains before any arranged marriage can be consummated.

Kevin Acklin, Mr. Peduto’s chief of staff and Urban Redevelopment Authority board chairman, said Thursday he was encouraged by the initial meetings he had this week with representatives of McCaffery Interests and Rubino Partners.

“Very positive initial discussions with both developers. [They’re] very eager to get started and also identified a willingness to work together to develop this building in a manner that achieves [URA goals],” he said.

The URA board voted earlier this month to negotiate with McCaffery and Rubino over the next three months in hopes of combining their competing visions for the terminal into one master development.

Advertise with us

McCaffery has plans to convert the terminal — which for decades was used as a hub for produce wholesalers — into mainly housing with some retail and office space, while Rubino wants to turn it into a giant marketplace anchored by vendors specializing in closeout merchandise.

Mr. Acklin said there likely will have to be modifications to the proposals, primarily McCaffery’s, to identify the section of the 1,533-foot-long terminal that would be used as a public marketplace, adding there are “some ideas floating around” about that. He previously has suggested that perhaps the western end of the building, at one time slated for demolition, could be used for that purpose.

But Mr. Acklin acknowledged there are still a number of thorny issues to be resolved if the arrangement is to work. Among them are the structure of the transaction, financing, the building footprint, how the project intersects with the Buncher Co.’s proposed $450 million riverfront office and residential development, and whether the terminal would be owned or leased.

The city is exploring several options regarding the latter, including retaining its ownership as a means of keeping the Strip landmark in public hands for future generations. Under such a scenario, the city still hopes to negotiate a deal with the developer to pay property taxes as if the terminal were privately owned.

Asked about the initial meeting, a spokeswoman for Rubino Partners said there’s “not really anything to talk about at this point.” Dan McCaffery, CEO of McCaffery Interests, could not be reached for comment.

Advertise with us

Mr. Acklin said follow-up meetings are planned to discuss outstanding issues.

“Our objective is to accommodate both housing and a public use. This wasn’t a one-size-fits-all solution,” he said.

“I think the message we gave is that we’re not going to dictate the outcome. They both mentioned they would be flexible, obviously subject to figuring out all of these variables, to having a development in the building that achieves both objectives.”

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.