Complying with federal regulations costs U.S. businesses more than $2 trillion each year, according to a new study commissioned by the National Association of Manufacturers.
The Washington, D.C., industry group said the costs of complying with regulations covering the environment, worker safety and other issues fall disproportionately on manufacturers and small businesses. The average manufacturing company pays compliance costs of $19,564 per employee per year, nearly double the average cost paid by all U.S. businesses, according to the study.
“There’s no question it’s harming our country’s economic growth,” said Jay Timmons, NAM president and CEO. “This is a hidden tax. It’s a hidden cost to the economy.”
The study was done by Lafayette College professors Nicole V. and W. Mark Crain, who are married.
A similar study the Crains conducted in 2010 for the U.S. Small Business Administration put regulatory costs at $1.75 trillion.
Critics said that study was flawed because it relied on opinion polling of business leaders who had a vested interest in overestimating regulatory costs. They also said the Crains failed to measure the benefits that regulations provide.
The Crains said they modified their research methods for their latest study. But one of their critics is not impressed.
James Goodwin, senior policy analyst for the Center for Progressive Reform in Washington, D.C., said the latest study still uses data based on surveys of business owners and relies on cost estimates made by the federal government’s Office of Management and Budget. Those estimates are oftentimes exaggerated because they are based in part on what businesses say compliance will cost, he said.
Mr. Goodwin said the manufacturers association again ignored the benefits of regulation.
“Only one side of this equation isn’t useful information. It creates confusion. It’s misleading,” he said.
Mr. Timmons agreed that regulations have benefits, but said the government must do a better job of balancing those benefits with the costs.
The manufacturers association study said businesses would have hired more workers, purchased new equipment and conducted more research if complying with regulations did not cost so much.
Mr. Goodwin said companies have record levels of cash at their disposal that they could invest in those growth initiatives if they wanted to.

The burden of federal regulations




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.