A Commonwealth Court judge granted a request Friday that she privately review 477 emails from the NCAA related to the Pennsylvania State University child-molestation scandal that the organization had argued were protected internal communications.
Judge Anne E. Covey ordered the NCAA to deliver the emails by noon next Friday for her to review as part of a lawsuit brought by State Sen. Jake Corman, R-Centre, over who would benefit from the $60 million fine the university agreed to pay to the NCAA.
The ruling follows the revelation this week of emails among NCAA officials indicating they were not certain they had the authority to impose sanctions and had decided to "bluff" Penn State into signing a consent decree that included the fine, a four-year bowl ban, and the loss of 60 scholarships.
The emails were made public in a court filing by Mr. Corman, whose district includes State College, and Pennsylvania Treasurer Rob McCord, requesting that Judge Covey review those that were being withheld to determine if they were relevant to the lawsuit. Those emails had been turned over by the NCAA to Corman during the lawsuit's discovery process.
The sanctions followed the 2011 arrest of Jerry Sandusky, a former assistant football coach, who was found guilty of child sex abuse and sent to prison.
In July 2012, Rodney Erickson, then Penn State's acting president, signed the consent decree following the release of an investigative report by former FBI Director Louis Freeh accusing top university officials of a cover-up.
Read More
An NCAA representative could not be reached for comment Friday night. In a statement Wednesday, the NCAA said the “selectively released e-mails” reflected debate and thorough consideration within the organization.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.