The defense attorney for state Sen. Jane Orie said this morning that the prosecution will use "an optical illusion" to try to prove his client's guilt.
"The commonwealth will present you with binder after binder to make you think they have a mountain of evidence when they've got nothing," attorney William Costopoulos said during his opening statement. "They're not as adept as David Copperfield, and you're going to see right through this."
The binders, the defense attorney said, will include thousands of pages of documents -- emails, letters, fundraiser lists -- designed to convince the jurors that more than just "de minimis" activity occurred, or things of such small import that they do not matter.
Ms. Orie's trial on charges that she used her legislative staff to campaign for both herself and her sister, now state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin, began this morning before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning.
The trial of another sister, Janine Orie, who is also charged in the case, was severed. Her case will be heard separately later.
In his nearly 90-minute opening statement, Assistant District Attorney Lawrence Claus told the jury of seven women and five men that the victims in the case were Pennsylvania taxpayers, who were responsible for funding the senator's legislative staff.
"These actions by the senator, directives by her, deprived the commonwealth, the taxpayers... the monies used to do this inappropriate work," Mr. Claus said. "The senator, literally, tilted the playing field against candidates who didn't have the luxury of having state employees to campaign for them."
She is charged with 26 counts, including theft of services, ethics violations, conspiracy and fabricating physical evidence. Charges of perjury, forgery and obstructing the administration of law were added last summer after the first trial of Jane and Janine Orie ended in a mistrial.
The prosecution indicated that the first witness to be called this afternoon will be Jennifer Rioja, the former intern in the senator's district office, whose phone call to the Allegheny County District Attorney's office in October 2009 initiated the investigation.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.